3 ms·
It strikes me as extremely odd to call this a "discovery". The vaccine was very specifically designed to work in exactly its unique mode to be effective against
by ncmncm 6y ago
It strikes me as extremely odd to call this a "discovery". The vaccine was very specifically designed to work in exactly its unique mode to be effective against one species of pathogen. We might equally well talk about SpaceX Starship being "discovered".
To me, it is invented, constructed, engineered, or created. What has been discovered?
- namenotrequired 6y agoThis is an interesting question. I'm honestly curious if anyone knows - why do we talk about, say, machines being invented but drugs and vaccines being discovered? (I get that you invent the drug, and then you discover whether it works. But the same is true for machines.)
- ncmncm 6y agoIt makes sense to talk about discovering a bioactive compound, such as from an herbal remedy, or by testing a family of related compounds. An engineered vaccine is a wholly different animal. The only other time we say "discover" about something manufactured is when somebody else did it. We can discover a meth lab, a Ponzi scheme, or (in principle) an alien civilization.