3 ms·
I’m curious if automotive systems used more generic controllers for cabin systems if shortages like this would be less or more severe. If the AC and the power
by hinkley 6y ago
I’m curious if automotive systems used more generic controllers for cabin systems if shortages like this would be less or more severe.
If the AC and the power seats and the cabin lights used the moral equivalent of a raspberry pi compute engine, would we see supply harder to disrupt, or massive consolidation that just makes these problems worse, for instance every single car plant shutting down for two weeks out of the same three months as the pause wends its way through the supply chain. Today a Chevrolet plant gets the only truckload, but Ram doesn’t run out until tomorrow due to transit delays.
- wlesieutre 6y agoThe mass market parts probably wouldn't stand up to car environments, these are expected to operate for years with temperatures that range from well below freezing in the winter to over 150 parked in the sun when it's hot out.
- colechristensen 6y agoThere are automotive rated parts which comes down to an increased temperature range and (where applicable) vibration tolerance, electrical transients, etc. Sometimes it involves different materials but usually it’s just more testing on an increased range. For example a part which handles electric current might be rated to 100mA at an ambient temperature of 20C but only 40mA at 60C or -40C. Regular consumer electronics you can just ignore these ranges as unreasonable but a car is going to get that hot or that cold so you have to have parts rated for those conditions.
- hinkley 6y ago> the moral equivalent of a raspberry pi compute engine I did not mean mass market parts when I said “moral equivalent” since that was not clear. I meant automotive grade controllers. I guess the real problem, besides shortages of the IC on the board as someone else said, would be connectors. The circuit boards aren’t just built different, the connectors are ruggedized and in some cases water/dirt resistant too. There’s no way you’ll use the same connector for a five way adjustable seat as for the cabin light controls. And if you did you couldn’t put any of them next to each other or someone plugs the defroster into the cruise control and somebody dies. Best you could do is a standard circuit board and custom housing that has the wiring harness, and at that point things look pretty similar to the status quo. Also relays in that situation are probably a bigger part of the wiring than I’m allowing.
- dapids 6y agoProblem is everything needs to be automotive grade components, and if the supply is already low such a type or in contention, they are going to cost a heck of a lot more than the absurdity which is the 100% additional cost for a automotive grade resistor or IC versus a consumer level component.
- amluto 6y agoThe RPi compute engine is a PCB, a fairly large number of components, and a complicated chipset meant for video processing and Linux. This is not what your power seat wants, and it’s probably considerably more expensive than what your seat wants. In any case, the current bottleneck is, to a vague approximation, a bottleneck on total output. An RPi compute module has a lot more mm^2 of silicon than a little ECU. You also likely can’t make a good RPi compute-like module on the larger-feature-size fabs that make ECUs.
- nottorp 6y agoAlso a RPi won't survive at car temperatures.
- sigstoat 6y ago> I’m curious if automotive systems used more generic controllers for cabin systems if shortages like this would be less or more severe. that wouldn't help. generic and not-generic controllers would still use ICs, and ICs are still what we're slowed down on. a more generic design might have to use more (or more complicated) ICs as well, to have more tolerant inputs. more generic/standardized controllers might help if there were limits on printed circuit board manufacturing, or board assembly capacity. (as those things get cheaper/easier/faster the more identical units you make. and yes, that applies to ICs as well, but all of the widely used microcontrollers / jellybean parts are already produced in huge volumes.)
- mulmen 6y agoThis is already the case. A new Chevy pickup and a new Ford pickup have the same transmission. BMW and Mercedes buy transmissions from ZF or other vendors. Bosch provides engine management systems to like... everyone. I'd be astonished if there are more than a dozen power seat motors in use across the entire new car fleet. Tesla is a notable exception because they actually make their own components, like the Model X Gull wing door actuators.
- hinkley 6y agoI meant within a single vehicle but that’s probably the best you’re going to get. It wasn’t until I was an adult living on the coast that I understood this and why Midwestern auto shops were so resistant to foreign cars. This process was still in development, and so while one set of brake assembly might fit twenty Chevy and Ford vehicles over a five model year period, you were always having to special order parts for the “weird” cars because you couldn’t keep them in inventory, and so you had to deal with a hostile customer who didn’t understand why their wife’s car got brakes in one day and the Subaru was going to take a week. They storm off to another shop and get the same answer.
- mulmen 6y agoAh yeah that is different then. I do wonder where these supply chains broke down specifically. Is it compute modules or specific chips/components? How feasible is it to have interchangeable compute modules with different internal implementations? My car was available with I think six different batteries depending on options but they are also two entirely different chemistries (AGM and lead-acid). If there is a lead-acid battery shortage for some reason presumably everything could have been AGM.
- mschuster91 6y agoThe car itself doesn't care about the battery chemistry at all - it's actually not even a different chemistry, only a different way to build them -, it's always a nominal voltage of 12V and a charge voltage of about 14V. You can put in whatever battery you want, in theory. Practically, your choice will be influenced by: - price (lead-acid are cheaper) - usage frequency (AGM have lower self discharge rates and can stand up for a year or more without charging, while a lead-acid will grow sulfate crystals in a matter of months) - peak current capacity and temperature range (again, AGM are better, and you must use a battery that can supply the crank with enough amps... and note that the crank will need more power in colder climates) - capacity (obviously... depending on options like a beefy sound system, service lights, antitheft systems or seat heaters, you need higher capacity)