5 ms·

Have you used a recent Macbook? The Macbook Pro keyboard is unique in that is is the only time in my life I have ever experienced a keyboard breaking. I think

Have you used a recent Macbook? The Macbook Pro keyboard is unique in that is is the only time in my life I have ever experienced a keyboard breaking. I think people are a little too nostalgic when talking about Apple build quality. There's a 2011 MBP here that still works well. But recent releases... no better than the competition really.

boboche 5y ago
AMEN to that. I still use my fully repairable MBP 2010 for web surfing and light tasks (with 8GB and a SSD its fine). On the Keyboard note, I've bought an expensive Eurocom (Clevo) Xeon laptop that had keyboard issues after a few years. Its not only apple that did bad with bad keyboard on expensive products (Fortunately I could repair it myself for 50$). Today apple product should ship with rossman videos and a SMD workstation if you plan to use them more than 3yrs ;)
theshrike79 5y ago
Are you aware that the latest generation has a new keyboard? It's not the fiasco that the previous super-slim one was.
- eertami 5y ago
  Once bitten, twice shy. I considered that keyboard to be designed to fail. I'm not interested in gambling that another component won't fail the same way. It's easier to use products that have not demonstrated such designed failures. The good news however is that due to this garbage tier engineering I've discovered that desktop Linux is more stable for me than post-Catalina OSX - I'd have probably never found this out otherwise.
  - jasonwatkinspdx 5y ago
    Designed to fail is preposterous. Apple lost a ton of money due to that problem, both directly in paying for repairs, and indirectly in damage to their stock price. It's pretty clear what happened, and it's unfortunate but banal: someone went too far with making the key mechanism as thin as possible, and all plastic to make it easier to manufacture. Ends up the plastic wasn't strong enough for the little pins in the mechanism. That's it. Just an ordinary design mistake. Embarrassing but no conspiracy. FWIW they've resolved it. The keyboard on this M1 MBA is perfectly fine.
    - nsxwolf 5y ago
      The new keyboard is what they should have had the last few years. A refinement of the scissor switch keyboard from the glory days of the MacBook. It's great.
    - minikites 5y ago
      >Apple lost a ton of money due to that problem, both directly in paying for repairs, and indirectly in damage to their stock price. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL I don't see any evidence that Apple's stock price was affected. Apple can ship any garbage (they shipped a keyboard they knew was defective for three years) and people will buy it because they're locked in to Apple's services, another reason they're pushing services so hard at the expense of the rest of the company.
    - r00fus 5y ago
      > It's pretty clear what happened, and it's unfortunate but banal: someone went too far with making the key mechanism as thin as possible I see it as a symptom of the Jony Ive ideology, untethered from realty by Jobs, poisoning Apple in the early 2010s. iOS7 flat UI, overthin devices, keyboards. Signs are pointing that Apple is recovering from this (new aTV remote).
FearlessNebula 5y ago
The keyboard has been fixed since 2019
BOOSTERHIDROGEN 5y ago
You have to test new keyboard on M1 MBA/MBP
- eertami 5y ago
  Test it for what exactly? All ultrabook keyboards are garbage, but they shouldn't out-right fail. "Testing" one isn't going to tell me if it will fail, it's just going to feel as crappy as the other keyboards. If a product fails within the first 10% of expected lifespan I'm no longer interested in that product. If it fails _AND_ the manufacturer refuses to take responsibility until months of bad press and class action lawsuits then I'd have to be insane to trust them with another device.
  - ben7799 5y ago
    The point is the keyboard on a 2018 Macbook when Jony Ive was allowed to push his nonsense is just not the same keyboard as on a current Macbooks. It's a different keyboard. Different mechanism, very different feel, larger key travel, much more comfortable. I have a 2018 i7 MBP and a 2020 M1. The keyboards feel incredibly different. On top of that the 2020 M1 has a real Escape key which is a huge upgrade for anyone in unix land/developer land, etc.. The 2019+ keyboard has had no controversy or reputation for failing. My 2018 one does feel like it's on it's last legs FWIW. It's a work machine.. just hoping to get a refresh before it dies.
ses1984 5y ago
Which competitor has a touchpad that’s equal to or better than apple?
- eertami 5y ago
  I'm probably not the person to ask, I only use the touchpad as a last resort. (Honestly I never even noticed that the apple touchpad was better than any other touchpad, but I understand that touchpad users will notice things I didn't.)
- lsaferite 5y ago
  That is certainly one area where I think Apple has no peer.
- ModernMech 5y ago
  I prefer the touchpad on my Surface Book 2 to the one on my Macbook Pro (2019). The one on my Macbook is comically huge, and I also am not in love with the feel/click noise compared to the Surface Book. YMMV.
  - macintux 5y ago
    Ideally there’s be no feel/click noise on an Apple trackpad. “Tap to click” is a revelation.
    - stjohnswarts 5y ago
      You know when you say stuff like "revelation" it really doesn't help your argument that you're not just fanboying out for apple?
    - ModernMech 5y ago
      Oh no, I much prefer the tactile response and sound of a physical click. But again, that's maybe just me.
  - ses1984 5y ago
    The bigger the better as far as I’m concerned that’s half the reason I went with a 15” model.
zepto 5y ago
> Have you used a recent Macbook? The Macbook Pro keyboard is unique in that is is the only time in my life I have ever experienced a keyboard breaking. Given that you know the keyboard has been fixed, is there a reason why you didn’t make it clear that you were talking about older machines and not current ones? You make it sound like the current machines have the flawed keyboard, which is not true as far as I am aware.
- skohan 5y ago
  I'm typing on a current-gen macbook, and the keyboard is fine. Butterfly keyboards were flawed, but I think it's also a bit disingenuous of the parent comment to imply that this is a reflection on overall mac build quality. Those generations of macs were bad products for several reasons, but the general build quality of those machines, and everything in Apple's line is quite high comparing to competitors

boboche 5y ago

AMEN to that. I still use my fully repairable MBP 2010 for web surfing and light tasks (with 8GB and a SSD its fine). On the Keyboard note, I've bought an expensive Eurocom (Clevo) Xeon laptop that had keyboard issues after a few years. Its not only apple that did bad with bad keyboard on expensive products (Fortunately I could repair it myself for 50$). Today apple product should ship with rossman videos and a SMD workstation if you plan to use them more than 3yrs ;)

theshrike79 5y ago

Are you aware that the latest generation has a new keyboard? It's not the fiasco that the previous super-slim one was.

eertami 5y ago
Once bitten, twice shy. I considered that keyboard to be designed to fail. I'm not interested in gambling that another component won't fail the same way. It's easier to use products that have not demonstrated such designed failures. The good news however is that due to this garbage tier engineering I've discovered that desktop Linux is more stable for me than post-Catalina OSX - I'd have probably never found this out otherwise.
- jasonwatkinspdx 5y ago
  Designed to fail is preposterous. Apple lost a ton of money due to that problem, both directly in paying for repairs, and indirectly in damage to their stock price. It's pretty clear what happened, and it's unfortunate but banal: someone went too far with making the key mechanism as thin as possible, and all plastic to make it easier to manufacture. Ends up the plastic wasn't strong enough for the little pins in the mechanism. That's it. Just an ordinary design mistake. Embarrassing but no conspiracy. FWIW they've resolved it. The keyboard on this M1 MBA is perfectly fine.
  - nsxwolf 5y ago
    The new keyboard is what they should have had the last few years. A refinement of the scissor switch keyboard from the glory days of the MacBook. It's great.
  - minikites 5y ago
    >Apple lost a ton of money due to that problem, both directly in paying for repairs, and indirectly in damage to their stock price. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL I don't see any evidence that Apple's stock price was affected. Apple can ship any garbage (they shipped a keyboard they knew was defective for three years) and people will buy it because they're locked in to Apple's services, another reason they're pushing services so hard at the expense of the rest of the company.
  - r00fus 5y ago
    > It's pretty clear what happened, and it's unfortunate but banal: someone went too far with making the key mechanism as thin as possible I see it as a symptom of the Jony Ive ideology, untethered from realty by Jobs, poisoning Apple in the early 2010s. iOS7 flat UI, overthin devices, keyboards. Signs are pointing that Apple is recovering from this (new aTV remote).

FearlessNebula 5y ago

The keyboard has been fixed since 2019

BOOSTERHIDROGEN 5y ago

You have to test new keyboard on M1 MBA/MBP

eertami 5y ago
Test it for what exactly? All ultrabook keyboards are garbage, but they shouldn't out-right fail. "Testing" one isn't going to tell me if it will fail, it's just going to feel as crappy as the other keyboards. If a product fails within the first 10% of expected lifespan I'm no longer interested in that product. If it fails _AND_ the manufacturer refuses to take responsibility until months of bad press and class action lawsuits then I'd have to be insane to trust them with another device.
- ben7799 5y ago
  The point is the keyboard on a 2018 Macbook when Jony Ive was allowed to push his nonsense is just not the same keyboard as on a current Macbooks. It's a different keyboard. Different mechanism, very different feel, larger key travel, much more comfortable. I have a 2018 i7 MBP and a 2020 M1. The keyboards feel incredibly different. On top of that the 2020 M1 has a real Escape key which is a huge upgrade for anyone in unix land/developer land, etc.. The 2019+ keyboard has had no controversy or reputation for failing. My 2018 one does feel like it's on it's last legs FWIW. It's a work machine.. just hoping to get a refresh before it dies.

ses1984 5y ago

Which competitor has a touchpad that’s equal to or better than apple?

eertami 5y ago
I'm probably not the person to ask, I only use the touchpad as a last resort. (Honestly I never even noticed that the apple touchpad was better than any other touchpad, but I understand that touchpad users will notice things I didn't.)
lsaferite 5y ago
That is certainly one area where I think Apple has no peer.
ModernMech 5y ago
I prefer the touchpad on my Surface Book 2 to the one on my Macbook Pro (2019). The one on my Macbook is comically huge, and I also am not in love with the feel/click noise compared to the Surface Book. YMMV.
- macintux 5y ago
  Ideally there’s be no feel/click noise on an Apple trackpad. “Tap to click” is a revelation.
  - stjohnswarts 5y ago
    You know when you say stuff like "revelation" it really doesn't help your argument that you're not just fanboying out for apple?
  - ModernMech 5y ago
    Oh no, I much prefer the tactile response and sound of a physical click. But again, that's maybe just me.
- ses1984 5y ago
  The bigger the better as far as I’m concerned that’s half the reason I went with a 15” model.

zepto 5y ago

> Have you used a recent Macbook? The Macbook Pro keyboard is unique in that is is the only time in my life I have ever experienced a keyboard breaking. Given that you know the keyboard has been fixed, is there a reason why you didn’t make it clear that you were talking about older machines and not current ones? You make it sound like the current machines have the flawed keyboard, which is not true as far as I am aware.

skohan 5y ago
I'm typing on a current-gen macbook, and the keyboard is fine. Butterfly keyboards were flawed, but I think it's also a bit disingenuous of the parent comment to imply that this is a reflection on overall mac build quality. Those generations of macs were bad products for several reasons, but the general build quality of those machines, and everything in Apple's line is quite high comparing to competitors