On a quick skim of some introductory parts I found: > When you have a variable in C, the value of that variable is in memory somewhere, at some address. Of cou

On a quick skim of some introductory parts I found: > When you have a variable in C, the value of that variable is in memory somewhere, at some address. Of course. After all, where else would it be? It would be in a register. Of course. Or it would be eliminated by a compiler optimization. Of course. Same error later on: > When you pass a value to a function,a copy of that value gets made in this magical mystery world known as the stack No. In most common cases, arguments will not be passed via the stack. This goes on to clarify in a footnote that the implementation might not actually use a stack, and that the stack has something to do with recursion. That part is true, but the values saved on the stack for recursing are not the same as function arguments. Neither in the Variadic Functions chapter nor anywhere else are the default argument promotions mentioned -- this will bite someone who tries to write a variadic function that gets floats out of the variadic argument list, which you cannot do, since passing a float to a variadic function promotes it to double. Speaking of floats... This is one of those tutorials that are very confused regarding their target audience. For example, in the "Variables" section it goes out of its way to define: "A “byte” is an 8-bit binary number. Think of it as an integer that can only hold the values from 0 to 255, inclusive." (which isn't the C definition, but this really is nit-picking) but then happily goes on to talk about Booleans and floats without explaining what those are. What reader has a background that would make this useful? Overall, from the little I've seen, I'd give this an initial rating of "broadly correct but with definite mistakes". Even if it were fully correct, I dislike the verbose style, and I wouldn't recommend this tutorial. For example, in the Hello World chapter, we have the following "explanation" of the line "#include <stdio.h>": > Now, what is this#include? GROSS! Well, it tells the C Preprocessor to pull the contents of another fileand insert it into the code rightthere.Wait—what’s a C Preprocessor? Good question. There are two stages (well, technically there are more thantwo, but hey, let’s pretend there are two and have a good laugh) to compilation: the preprocessor and thecompiler. Anything that starts with pound sign, or “octothorpe”, (#) is something the preprocessor operateson before the compiler even gets started. Commonpreprocessor directives, as they’re called, are#includeand#define. More on that later.Before we go on, why would I even begin to bother pointing out that a pound sign is called an octothorpe?The answer is simple: I think the word octothorpe is so excellently funny, I have to gratuitously spread itsname around whenever I get the opportunity. Octothorpe. Octothorpe, octothorpe, octothorpe.Soanyway. After the C preprocessor has finished preprocessing everything, the results are ready for thecompiler to take them and produceassembly code8,machine code9, or whatever it’s about to do. Don’t worryabout the technical details of compilation for now; just know that your source runs through the preprocessor,then the output of that runs through the compiler, then that produces an executable for you to run. Octothorpe.What about the rest of the line? What’s<stdio.h>? That is what is known as aheader file. It’s the dot-hat the end that gives it away. In fact it’s the “Standard I/O” (stdio) header file that you will grow to knowand love. It contains preprocessor directives and function prototypes (more on that later) for common inputand output needs. For our demo program, we’re outputting the string “Hello, World!”, so we in particularneed the function prototype for theprintf()function from this header file. Basically, if we tried to useprintf()without#include <stdio.h>, the compiler would have complained to us about it.How did I know I needed to#include <stdio.h>forprintf()? Answer: it’s in the documentation. Ifyou’re on a Unix system,man printfand it’ll tell you right at the top of the man page what header files are required. Or see the reference section in this book.:-)Holy moly. That was all to cover the first line! But, let’s face it, it has been completely dissected. No mysteryshall remain! Only one sentence of this is relevant for an introductory Hello World chapter: "Basically, if we tried to use printf() without #include <stdio.h>, the compiler would have complained to us about it." None of the rest is relevant or helpful to a beginner who is just seeing their first ever C program. Also "completely dissected" isn't true either; there is a lot more to be said about headers.