4 ms·
Do people really think we are investing any significant amount of resources into Mars today? A few national space agencies have launched flyby or rover mission
by paxys 6y ago
Do people really think we are investing any significant amount of resources into Mars today?
A few national space agencies have launched flyby or rover missions, with a total cost of maybe $10-$20 billion combined over many decades. You could even argue that we have recovered some chunk of that in scientific knowledge.
There are ~5 private companies with any plans involving Mars, and I'd say all but one are scams.
SpaceX has Mars as a long term mission, but everything they are doing at present (mainly satellite launches) firmly involves Earth. All their Mars talk right now is marketing and PR, nothing more. Their total spending to date is also in the single digit billions.
All this money put together is a rounding error compared to the sums involved on every side of the global warming debate. The total number of people who have any portion of their productive work involve Mars is probably in the hundreds or low thousands.
Say we did get rid of all these NASA missions and even SpaceX entirely, how would that help Earth?
People scroll through Twitter and are convinced that we are just about to set up a Mars base, when the reality is that none of us will likely see a human step on Mars in our lifetime.
- pron 6y agoWhile you are correct, I don't think that's at all the point the website is making. I don't know if the point the site is trying to make is an effective one, but it's about focusing attention and inspiration, not direct financial resources.
- paxys 6y agoEven then, in my experience the set of people who are enthusiastic about Mars/space exploration fully overlaps with those who strongly care about climate change and the environment in general. It has never been about picking one over the other. They should instead invest the time and money in reaching out to people and corporations who don't give a shit about either one.
- Seb-C 6y agoIf we had invested in space exploration the same amount of resources we are investing in ads, tracking, finance and bitcoin, we would already have tourists in the asteroid belt, the climate/energy issue would be solved, and we would probably enjoy many other incredible health and food-related technologies. Complaining about the ridiculously small amounts of resources currently invested in space exploration is really short minded.
- koheripbal 6y agoThis is a poor argument - especially if you include finance. Finance makes large scale project possible by providing developers access to capital via the bond market.
- antisol 6y agoAnd what role does finance play in a society where money isn't a thing? Finance is only a drain on actual resources. Think of all the accountants that could have been out there creating things and doing useful stuff rather than playing make-believe with numbers. That genius who invented that finance thing you like might possibly have come up with a grand unified theory thing if he had focused on something useful rather than finance.
- koheripbal 6y agoFinance was invented out of necessity. People in ancient Egypt needed finance to feed people. It's not some esoteric concept. Just because you don't understand it, doesn't mean it holds no value.
- antisol 6y agoNo, people in ancient Egypt needed food to feed people.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 6y agoSimilarly they needed crops, and not the mathematics to accurately determine the area of farm plots.
- antisol 6y ago"they needed crops" They did? The Ancient Egyptions were obligate herbivores? Huh. I guess you really do learn something new every day.