3 ms·
What this attempt really revealed, IMHO, is how desperate for fresh cash a lot of these top clubs are. In particular, Juventus and Real Madrid (and Manchester U
by toyg 6y ago
What this attempt really revealed, IMHO, is how desperate for fresh cash a lot of these top clubs are. In particular, Juventus and Real Madrid (and Manchester United while the Glazer looters stay at the helm) have monstrous debts that risk destroying them as soon as they don’t dominate any competition for a few years. This is what they are saying when they talk about “saving football”: Florentino Perez and Andrea Agnelli are genuinely trying to save their clubs from self-destruction. Their sense of entitlement is such that they cannot fathom renouncing their position (i.e. selling big players and being weaker for some time), but they know sooner or later the debts will be due.
I hate the ESL/NBA concept for football, but something still has to be done to reduce these excesses. Financial Fair Play has not worked well enough for top clubs, the market for players remains fundamentally inflated by a handful of oligarchs. I hope that UEFA takes the legitimacy capital earned this week to make some real changes in this area.
- pjmlp 6y agoSadly it shows how far the sport has moved from the founding principles when playing for money was considered dirty and caused even arguments between football clubs across UK, about 100 years ago.
- inglor_cz 6y agoA lot has changed with the advent of TV. Suddenly you could have millions and millions of fans instead of thousands. And a corresponding advertising opportunity. Few people would let such an opportunity lie on a pavement without picking it up, especially given the fact that the recollections of the Great Depression were still within living memory.
- riffraff 6y agoPerez, Agnelli and others have often mentioned "football can't go without this", but what they mean is "I can't go on like this". Some of the big clubs have basically been financially mismanaged for years, but it's not about "football" it's about Juventus, Real Madrid etc. I wish we'd use salary caps (but those are trivial to hack around) and max transfer caps (ditto) and reduced shortlists with a mandatory % of youths. And surely the UEFA can be managed better. But the truth is these clubs are the "badly managed too big too fail bank" of football.
- estomagordo 6y agoSurely a salary cap would only benefit the big club owners? Unless you count non-consequence for financial mismanagement of the biggest clubs as a win.
- toyg 6y agoIf the cap is per-team, it would stop top clubs from building “galactico” teams packed with superstars: if you spend a ton on Ronaldo you then have to pay peanuts for other team members. This is basically the NBA model, where any franchise can typically afford a superstar only in one or two roles. Hence why very few NBA franchises have historically managed to win back-to-back titles for several years: every season you have to cut corners somewhere.
- estomagordo 6y agoNot that I'm a big advocate of the players' economy or anything, but effectively a salary cap is a financial transfer from the players to the ownership, no? Plus, I assume a salary cap wouldn't be EU compliant.
- toyg 6y agoOn a per-player basis no, it wouldn't be legal. But IMHO it must be doable in other ways; Formula1 for example has just introduced one, and I've not heard any noise about getting challenged from drivers or engineers. Financial Fair Play was initially conceived as a way to basically create such caps informally (since clubs would not be supposed to spend beyond their means) but it was then implemented to effectively be a moat for currently-rich clubs; in that form, it was eventually destroyed by the sheikh owner of Manchester City. If UEFA were to try again to build a sincere level-playing field for rich and poor clubs alike, I reckon governments and judges wouldn't stand in the way ("sport law" is a bit of a grey area in practice). Whether a cap is a "financial transfer from players to ownership", really depends on how the surplus is then channelled. If it goes towards actual development of the club and the sport (better long-term financial investments to keep clubs solvent, higher solidarity payments down the pyramids, more money for academies, etc), I wouldn't see it as objectionable.
- estomagordo 6y agoI think most probably the situation will sort itself out. If clubs such as Real Madrid finally implode, then football will remain ever as strong. Those players will just go somewhere else and a different club will start to win championships. And really, as money are involved, I do have to expect that no matter what your name is, there has got to be a point where the loan givers and stakeholders finally have had enough. As an aside, I am not surprised to see this spearheaded by Real Madrid and Juventus. I am however a bit surprised to not see Barcelona take a more active role, seeing how their financial peril seems to possibly be the worst out of the lot.
- toyg 6y agoBarcelona’s ownership model is weaker than Real or Juventus: directors depend on actual club member-owners who can vote them out. As such, they are forced to keep an ear to the ground - which is why the Barça top-man, Juan Laporta, negotiated an extra clause in their ESL contract to subordinate their joining to popular acceptance via a vote. Hence why they kept a low profile: Laporta got back on top only two months ago, after the previous board was basically kicked out in disgrace; he’s still too weak to make big waves. In theory Real Madrid has similar constraints, but Florentino Perez, over the years, has developed an iron grip that is very hard to remove (he can/could guarantee massive loans from friends in the banking system, which are then used to buy the “galactico” players that members crave). The Agnelli/Elkann family owns Juventus outright. As far as I know, no Italian club has “democratic” elements - a few are publicly floated but most are just private businesses.
- estomagordo 6y agoAh yes, that is insightful, particularly on the differences between Real Madrid and Barcelona. Thanks.
- zwaps 6y agoGiven the fact that teams like Bayern Munich, who also win the champions league regularly, have zero debt, I am less sympathetic to teams like Real Madrid, Barca or Juventus. It's simply mismanagement. You do not need to buy every promising player to be successful. It is also not the job of all other European teams to bail you out.
- dagw 6y agoBayern Munich, who also win the champions league regularly You're looking at the wrong league table. The owners don't care about winning that league, they care about winning this league: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes%27_list_of_the_most_valuable_sports_teams https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes%27_list_of_the_most_val....
- username90 6y agoBut that is basically anti value, how much money they managed to suck out of the economy. If you can have the same soccer but society pays less money for it wouldn't that be better? It isn't like there is a lack of players.