3 ms·
Capital gains default to being taxed at the same rate as income in this country (as they should be). There are exceptions for certain long term capital gains, a
by Jackson12 5y ago
Capital gains default to being taxed at the same rate as income in this country (as they should be). There are exceptions for certain long term capital gains, and for qualified dividends.
The rationale for this is that corporate profits are already taxed. The effective tax rate is about 25% for US corporations. For income from corporate profits to be taxed at the same rate as normal income, it should be taxed at a lesser rate once it's been distributed via dividends or buybacks (which is how the system is set up).
Changing the system would have several negative effects. It would encourage companies to take on leverage. Interest expenses are deductible for the purposes of corporate taxes. While interest earnings are and have always been taxed as ordinary income. So companies would likely shift their balance sheets to compensate. It would also make short term speculative trading more attractive for US citizens (and lord knows we have enough of that). And lead to greater foreign ownership of US equities, which is not necessarily desirable.
There are certainly fairly indefensible aspects of the US tax code. This just isn't one of them.
There's also an interesting argument that it's less distortionary to tax wage income than investment income. Because wages (and especially the variation thereof) are substantially driven by unearned human capital endowments.
- bjtitus 5y ago> Capital gains generally are taxed at the same rate as income in this country Maybe I'm missing something but the "Sales of Capital Assets Reported on Individual Tax" from 2012 shows 7.5x as many long term Capital Gains as short term. https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-sales-of-capital-assets-reported-on-individual-tax-returns#_tables https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-sales-of-capita... Doesn't this mean the majority of individual investment gains are not taxed as income?
- Jackson12 5y agoYou're right. That's a slightly misleading way to put it, and I have revised my original post. My point was that the "default" method of taxation is the same as ordinary income. Long term capital gains and qualified dividends are legally an exception to that rule. Though I don't think it diminishes my broader point.