4 ms·
I'm skeptical of any sorting of things into two bins, people or otherwise. https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-12-28 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-
by colechristensen 6y ago
I'm skeptical of any sorting of things into two bins, people or otherwise.
https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-12-28 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-12-28
You do have a point though (why I recall decade old comics as conversation pieces and not people's names... sigh) There are a lot of people on "mount stupid", in fact the chance that someone talking about a subject is trapped in the overconfidence of mount stupid is very high. In other words, most of the people you'll hear talking about something are entirely full of shit. (this is a large source of problems in our time)
There are people who don't know anything and realize it, then there are a whole lot of people who know enough to be aware that their knowledge is limited and don't want to try to talk over the overconfident folks (refuting someone sure of themselves is a lot more difficult than jabbering about your own feelings)
The people who really do know a whole lot and have the confidence to match are rare.
One thing that sticks out on HN are long discussions about things that folks have not much of an idea about. Non-computer-related engineering and farming threads are usually a shitshow of overconfident nonsense. Something to notice about computer people is they have the confidence that they can figure anything out (generally good) but frequently lack the wisdom to be aware of their knowledge (generally bad).
- incanus77 6y ago> I'm skeptical of any sorting of things into two bins, people or otherwise. Reminds me of the saying that there are 10 kinds of people in the world: those who understand binary and those who don’t.
- philipswood 6y ago10 kind of people: Those who understand binary, Those who don't, Those who understand ternary...
- harperlee 6y ago> I'm skeptical of any sorting of things into two bins, people or otherwise. I get what you are saying, but let me elaborate it a little bit for fun. If you project anything into one dimension and define a threshold, you have 2 bins, and you describe it with 1 bit. The fact that you are projecting does not make it an suspicious oversimplification per se. You can then add more dimensions into study and further classify the part of reality under study, and get more fancy with your bins, but from several points of view, there will be one master bit - that is, you have a classification tree, and a first level classification. So you can for sure talk about 2 bins, irrespective that there are other ways to look at the data, or funny cases near the threshold. So for example it makes sense to talk about people from Fidji vs. people not from Fidji in some contexts, and that should not be suspicious. So really what we should be suspect is from people who constantly jump to oversimplified models of reality to make grandiose takes on reality without first spending some time in explaining why that dimension dominates over others, why that threshold in particular, and why alternatives are not so useful as this simple model.