5 ms·
Makes a lot of sense to me that each department handles their own law enforcement, and can set the priorities they prefer. One centralized Federal Police Depar
by BurningFrog 6y ago
Makes a lot of sense to me that each department handles their own law enforcement, and can set the priorities they prefer.
One centralized Federal Police Department would be a single point of failure and bureaucratic nightmare.
Imagine if there were not State and local police departments. Just the FBI managing every shoplifting arrest in the country.
- alisonatwork 6y agoOn the flip side, there are plenty of countries that do just have a national police force, or a handful of regional departments, and don't have tens of thousands of independent police forces like America does. They tend to do just fine.
- hattar 6y agoAny with a population and land spread comparable to the US? I imagine that would make more sense in a small country with low diversity of terrain/population/etc.
- tmccrary55 6y agoPlus a national police force is basically illegal and unconstitutional in the US.
- banannaise 6y agoGosh, who's going to notify the feds in Portland of this?
- girvo 6y agoLots of countries do just that though, without the crazy specific separation and specialisation that America does.
- fastball 6y agoWhich ones and how big are they?
- cycomanic 6y agoPretty much every western country. Sweden, France, Germany to give three examples.
- fastball 6y agoRight, so countries the size of a single US state.
- sunshineforever 6y agoThe US divides it's police by town, not by state. And France and Germany are each twice as populous as the most populous US state. So you're not really correct. There's absolutely no reason why having a single bureaucracy wouldn't work well. It actually seems like it would be much easier to have a single bureaucracy.
- Kalium 6y agoAlso, counties often have their own sheriffs with a separate set of powers and responsibilities. Sometimes court systems have their own enforcement arms, separate from other agencies. The US often seems to have more layers of administration and law-making than some other places. Making individual officers work through which set of powers and laws they're dealing with in a given moment seems like it might at times be a daunting prospect. You could in theory organize them into a single bureau, but I suspect you'd inevitably wind up with specialized sections to deal with the particular laws in given cities.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoSheriffs and State Troopers ???.
- 6y ago