3 ms·
> Most people plead out because they’re ridiculously guilty. Most people plead out because they can't afford expensive trials. It's also a rational choice whe
by heavyset_go 6y ago
> Most people plead out because they’re ridiculously guilty.
Most people plead out because they can't afford expensive trials.
It's also a rational choice when prosecutors promise that they'll throw the book at you if you go to trial, and it's often your word against the word of cops, prosecutors and the expensive expert witnesses they can afford to hire but you can't. Juries and judges tend to side with law enforcement because they're authority figures and valued members of the justice system, after all.
- tptacek 6y agoIt's a little strange to me to think that the system would be working optimally if most people went to trial. A very big reason you don't take your criminal case to trial is if the prosecutors have you dead to rights, and the risk to reward is bad. If most people went to trial, that'd suggest that prosecutors are taking a lot of fliers on cases that they don't have strong evidence on. Which seems like... a bad thing?
- sneak 6y agoThe issue is that to a jury, being in the defendant's seat is strike one, having a cop testify against you is strike two... it doesn't take much to convict the innocent if a DA and the police start pushing for it.
- tptacek 6y agoOk, but that makes my argument stronger: if trial wins are practically a lay-up for the prosecution, you have to be prosecuting seriously dogshit cases to make going to trial attractive for a majority of your defendants.
- sneak 6y agoIs your argument that marginal cases would go to trial? I think it is the case that marginal cases would take a no-jail plea bargain. Going to trial on a marginal case with a public defender probably increases the risk of imprisonment versus taking a guilty plea that guarantees no jail time (but a criminal record).
- tptacek 6y agoWhat I'm saying is that in a well run DA's office, a docket consisting mostly of cases that plead out is what you'd want to see, because the alternative suggests that prosecutors are bringing shaky cases to court, which they should not do, because prosecution itself inflicts grievous costs on defendants.
- sneak 6y agoSure, but that is indistinguishable in the numbers from an out of control law enforcement system where there is a high conviction rate against even the innocent that leads to higher incidence of innocent people making a guilty plea to avoid jail and expense. Of course, that percentage isn't broken out because everyone in here is innocent.
- rayiner 6y agoPeople who can’t afford a lawyer will have a public defender appointed. Virtually none of these cases involves expert testimony. My wife did a pro bono murder trial a couple of years ago. (If your case is at all interesting high end law firms will often represent you for free.) They showed the jury CCTV from all over the city literally following the accused from murder scene to his house. Just cutting from one camera to the other showing the jury exactly what happened after the murder. Instead of recycling conventional wisdom, head over to your local federal court and sit in on some sentencing hearings (these are public). There will be a plea colloquy with the accused and the prosecutor will lay out all the supporting evidence. It’s quite eye opening.