4 ms·
There is significant tradition in the criminal justice system for the error bias to be in the other direction (in theory, if not in practice): https://en.wikip
by sneak 6y ago
There is significant tradition in the criminal justice system for the error bias to be in the other direction (in theory, if not in practice):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
I believe that to be "working as designed" we would see a lot more guilty people going free than innocent people being convicted.
- rayiner 6y ago> I believe that to be "working as designed" we would see a lot more guilty people going free than innocent people being convicted How do you know that’s not the case?
- sneak 6y agoConviction and plea bargain rates. Most (>90%) people who are charged (in the US) end up with either a guilty verdict or a guilty plea. IIRC even the ones that don't plead out are ~90% conviction rate, at least at the federal level. Doesn't jive at all with what we know of competence and bias levels observed in police and prosecutors in the US.
- rayiner 6y agoMost people plead out because they’re ridiculously guilty. I’m a crunchy hippie on criminal justice, but I’ve also seen these cases first hand working for an appellate judge. Prosecutors go after cases that are open and shut. You wouldn’t believe how much evidence there is in a typical case that doesn’t go to trial. They have the guy on CCTV with stolen goods in his car and cell phone records of fencing. Innocence Projects weed out hundreds of meritless requests for help for the relatively few meritorious cases they take.
- sneak 6y ago> Most people plead out because they’re ridiculously guilty. I know many innocent people who plead out to avoid jail because they're looking at $250k in legal bills and a ~90% trial conviction rate. Juries, being amateurs, are not very good at avoiding bias, as they are completely untrained. I'm not so sure that plea bargain rates are indicative of guilt either way.
- rayiner 6y agoHow many people who plead do you think have enough money not to be eligible for a PD? And how do you know “many innocent people who plead out?”
- ncmncm 6y agoI am completely sure they are not indicative of anything, in any way, shape or form. Besides legal expenses and risk of being convicted anyway, being in jail tends to result in being fired, defaulting on your home and car loans, and leaving your family destitute.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Most people plead out because they’re ridiculously guilty. Most people plead out because they can't afford expensive trials. It's also a rational choice when prosecutors promise that they'll throw the book at you if you go to trial, and it's often your word against the word of cops, prosecutors and the expensive expert witnesses they can afford to hire but you can't. Juries and judges tend to side with law enforcement because they're authority figures and valued members of the justice system, after all.
- tptacek 6y agoIt's a little strange to me to think that the system would be working optimally if most people went to trial. A very big reason you don't take your criminal case to trial is if the prosecutors have you dead to rights, and the risk to reward is bad. If most people went to trial, that'd suggest that prosecutors are taking a lot of fliers on cases that they don't have strong evidence on. Which seems like... a bad thing?
- sneak 6y agoThe issue is that to a jury, being in the defendant's seat is strike one, having a cop testify against you is strike two... it doesn't take much to convict the innocent if a DA and the police start pushing for it.
- tptacek 6y agoOk, but that makes my argument stronger: if trial wins are practically a lay-up for the prosecution, you have to be prosecuting seriously dogshit cases to make going to trial attractive for a majority of your defendants.
- sneak 6y agoIs your argument that marginal cases would go to trial? I think it is the case that marginal cases would take a no-jail plea bargain. Going to trial on a marginal case with a public defender probably increases the risk of imprisonment versus taking a guilty plea that guarantees no jail time (but a criminal record).
- SomeCallMeTim 6y agoI was on a jury for a trial where they had crap on the kid accused of conspiracy to create meth. He drove an old high school friend, who he hadn't seen for years, to a park. He drove into a parking lot on the way and turned around "as if trying to avoid tails." He returned to the car and the undercover cop put the key back in his hand after putting ingredients in the car. AND...he was being accused of conspiracy (which raises the seriousness of the crime to a felony!) to create meth because...there were drug ingredients in the car and the keys were in his hand. He'd spent his time at the park napping on the grass with his hat over his head. Or, as the cops testified, "probably acting as a lookout." We of course said "not guilty." No one even wanted to argue. No idea why they thought they had a case. But the kid in this case was white. I could totally see a black kid deciding that accepting a "lesser plea" would have been preferable to taking a chance on a 95%+ white jury (was in a predominantly white area; I don't think there was a single black juror, though I wasn't keeping count).
- jhgb 6y ago> Most people plead out because they’re ridiculously guilty. "Most people" can be as low as 51%, which is not very useful here.
- gweinberg 6y agoYeah, and there are a lot of people who are most likely guilty who never even get charged. A prosecutor won't want to take up a case when he thinks the evidence is in the zone between "preponderance" and "beyond reasonable doubt".
- ncmncm 6y agoIf the prosecutor can get somebody to plead guilty before they are charged, then he doesn't even need to think about the value of the evidence--or, indeed, about whether the person actually did anything. A guilty plea is even better for his reputation than a conviction, because he can get lots of those done in a day. Sure, somebody who looks prepared to lawyer up often won't be charged.