4 ms·
I'm surprised not to see any consideration of second-order effects. For example, if getting rid of the death penalty even slightly decreases the disincentive fo
by gnicholas 6y ago
I'm surprised not to see any consideration of second-order effects. For example, if getting rid of the death penalty even slightly decreases the disincentive for committing crime, it's quite possible that more lives would be lost than saved.
In any given year, there are relatively few executions in the US — in recent years it has been around 25. [1] If we assume the 4% figure as correct, then every four years there is one innocent person who is executed.
That is a terrible outcome. But it's quite possible that eliminating the death penalty completely would cause at least 2 more deaths every four years.
I'm not advocating for or against the death penalty — just pointing out that if the goal is to minimize the death of innocent people, we might want to consider second-order effects. I will admit that state-sanctioned killing of innocent people seems worse than general killing of innocent people. At the same time, if the government makes a decision that it knows will result in a net increase in the number of innocent people killed, the fact that they're not sticking a needle into the arm of the innocent people who will die is somewhat less of a salient distinction.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_the_Unit...
- rmorey 6y agohttps://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/deterrence https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/deterrence
- gnicholas 6y agoI'm aware that there is not strong evidence of a global deterrent effect. However, if we are looking to offset something like 1 death every four years, the magnitude of a countervailing effect could be small enough to be lost in the 'noise' of the existing research studies, but still be larger than the .25 annual deaths that it's being measured against. I would also point out that looking at state-level differences in death penalty policies isn't as likely to pick up changes in attitudes among criminals. If the federal government outlawed the death penalty, there would be much broader awareness of the change (and therefore more likelihood of a change in criminal behavior).
- cjfd 6y agoGo back to grade school and learn your percentages anew. You are treating them very badly.