6 ms·
This is a terrible idea. I do not believe this, but I was raised around a lot of people who sincerely, devoutly, believe that in the "end times" of the world, a
by kstrauser 6y ago
This is a terrible idea. I do not believe this, but I was raised around a lot of people who sincerely, devoutly, believe that in the "end times" of the world, a literally Satanic commerce system will require people to buy and sell goods with imprints on their the foreheads or the palms of their hands.[0]
If you think we've faced some goofy religion-driven complaints about stuff in the past, wait until that crowd finds out Jeff Bezos wants them to buy his stuff with the Mark of the Beast (which is how they'll describe it). People will lose their minds about this. I am completely serious.
Even if the idea of the payment system itself has merit, I predict a terribly chilly cultural reception to the idea.
[0]https://biblehub.com/revelation/13-16.htm https://biblehub.com/revelation/13-16.htm
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> a lot of people who sincerely, devoutly, believe that in the "end times" of the world, a literally Satanic commerce system will require people to buy and sell goods with imprints on their the foreheads or the palms of their hands I imagine the overlap between Whole Foods customers and this lot is sparse. If anything, it sounds like a great opportunity for free marketing.
- kstrauser 6y agoWell, if this fully launches, I'd expect them to become completely disjoint sets. But don't for a second believe that the "Satan is coming for us any moment now" crowd doesn't have an awful lot of money and power. I'm not describing a tiny pocket of people who eschew physical possessions, but a rather large portion of the US.
- king_magic 6y ago> If anything, it sounds like a great opportunity for free marketing. Right? I'd shop at Satan's grocery store.
- wrinkl3 6y agoIs there a huge overlap between the types of people who worry about this and Whole Foods customers?
- kstrauser 6y agoI'm generalizing here, but what I've described is a very common belief among evangelicals. The first source I found on Google[0] puts that at a very large percentage of the population in the US midwest and south. [0] https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/us-states-by-evangelical-protestant-population.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/us-states-by-evangelical...
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI would not expect that crowd to overlap with Whole Foods customers.
- riversflow 6y agoWhy? I see this sentiment echoed many times. Its confusing to me at least because it’s not like Whole Foods has direct competition for high end food stuffs in most markets I’ve seen. I know a handful of these types people and they are more likely than average to only buy the best foods, with Whole Foods being their major retailer of choice.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI guess I’m assuming from the religious conservatives I know that they wouldn’t be into the organic/hippy/overpriced food market.
- kstrauser 6y agoThere are a not-small number of people who follow Joel Osteen and other "prosperity gospel" preachers who think God would want them to have the very best, and if that means organic/hippy/overpriced, then so be it.
- blackearl 6y agoRed Letter Media featured an Asian Christianity tape from long ago that had a bit about how products can't have barcodes on them because it's the number of the beast or some craziness. https://youtu.be/ceUSZBMeREY?t=2017 https://youtu.be/ceUSZBMeREY?t=2017
- ransom1538 6y agoCashier security: "Sorry Mr. Null (NULL), looks like your palm isn't scanning, you need to put the items back in this bin." Cashier security: "Sure.... Sorry Mr. Null (NULL), you will have to work this out with amazon."
- meepmorp 6y agoThe first thing I thought was “It’s the mark of the beast on the right hand to buy stuff! Good job, marketing staff!”
- kstrauser 6y agoRight? It seems like their product team either has zero evangelical Christians on staff, or they ignored the people who were probably shouting "this is not going to go over well" in meetings. Things like this are why it's so critical to have people with diverse backgrounds around you. Otherwise you tend not to know about significant cultural differences until it's too late.
- tohnjitor 6y agoThe idea itself is not goofy?
- krapp 6y agoI mean yes, but those people have believed just about everything from drivers licenses to social security numbers to RFID to the COVID vaccine was the Mark of the Beast. Every new paradigm in communication, every form of government-issued identification, the serial numbers on dollar bills. It's fun to laugh at their constant stupidity, but also perfectly safe to ignore them from a political and economic standpoint.
- ccn0p 6y agomaybe some people believe those things, but simply not true to grossly overgeneralize as those people because the bible is pretty clear about the mark of the beast being on the hand or the forehead.
- krapp 6y agoIt is the same people taking a vague and cryptic text which was probably originally about Nero Caesar and applying the same flawed pins-and-string conspiracy theory reasoning to a few cherry-picked details in order to express their constant fear of the future. The bible says a lot of things about the mark of the beast that conveniently get ignored whenever evangelicals think they've spotted it, and they think they spot it all the time. They've never been right, and they're never going to be right.
- trav4225 6y agoYeah, the lack of a consistent interpretive hermeneutic for biblical texts is a big cause of this kind of confusion. Incidentally, there is a lot of scholarly support for the hypothesis that, in context, the forward-looking statements in the book of Revelation (and other New Testament texts) are largely or completely about first-century events (see topics such as preterism, covenant eschatology, full preterism, etc.). Understanding documents that were written thousands of years ago, in a cultural and linguistic milieu far different than that of western civilization, is difficult for modern westerners. People ought to study more before jumping to outlandish conclusions about the meaning of such texts.
- pyinstallwoes 6y agoSo like the vaccine passport?
- adkadskhj 6y agoI agree with you; A decision that has nothing to do with them is likely to suffer massive backlash. Because if the world doesn't fit their narrative, they will make it so. I look forward to it. Not saying it's the best strategic move by Amazon, but day by day i grow more tired of the fallout of christians. Yea, maybe it's just fringe christians.. but if there are reasonable people in their ranks, they're happily silent. They happily co-exist with extremists, and the affect that's having on society is frustrating to me. If they just lived their life and didn't try to bully everyone else into alignment with their beliefs i'd be more sympathetic. But the less they get special treatment these days the more "Anti christian" they claim everyone is. As if the secular population is out there attacking them. Equality seems persecution to them.
- kstrauser 6y agoA lot of it seems to come down to a business decision: how large of a market demographic are we willing to piss off, and how badly? On one hand, if you name a new product after a Roman god, there are likely to be at least some people who are offended that you're using their deities name, but that's probably going to be a teensy amount of people. On another, if you name your new product "Pope Is A Dope", a pretty large chunk of your customer base is likely to take their business elsewhere. So just purely from a business point of view, Amazon needs to evaluate how much they're willing to annoy evangelicals. It's very possible they've run the numbers and decided they're OK with this for all the reasons you state and more. I think it's also at least a little possible that it simply hadn't occurred to them that some people might not like the idea for religious reasons. If they launched their new "Zeus the Deuce" product and suddenly a few people people rose up and started writing op-eds and organizing boycotts over it, I'd expect someone to be pretty surprised. I think this might be along those lines.