3 ms·
Unless those ethical concerns directly impact your own team, then that's deeply unprofessional and unethical on your part, and you should reconsider your priori
by crazygringo 6y ago
Unless those ethical concerns directly impact your own team, then that's deeply unprofessional and unethical on your part, and you should reconsider your priorities.
Who appointed you moral judge of others? You discriminating against candidates based on their moral views unrelated to their work is no different from discriminating based on religion or political party affiliation.
It is legitimately within your purview to ensure that that a candidate doesn't have moral objections to the work they'll be expected to do, as well as look for legitimate objective red flags such as previously embezzling from an employer.
But the idea that you'd appoint yourself as some kind of moral purity guardian is deeply objectionable in a world where people legitimately disagree in good faith over ethical issues. You should re-examine this.
- mhuffman 6y agoHey, don't you know that "culture fit" means hating all the same things that I hate?
- driverdan 6y ago> Unless those ethical concerns directly impact your own team Privacy issues impact every team. The threat of SLAPP lawsuits impacts every person willing to exercise their freedom of speech. If someone has worked for a company that does privacy invasive unethical things then it's reasonable to assume they'd be fine with doing privacy invasive unethical things somewhere else.
- crazygringo 6y agoIt's up to a company to set its own policies around privacy and ensure employees follow them. The fact that an employee worked somewhere with different, or opposed, privacy policies, doesn't mean they're unable to follow yours, any more than the fact that working at a company that used a 4-space-width tab to indent code means they're unable to follow your guideline of two-space indents. What does it matter if an employee would be fine doing what you consider to be privacy invasive things at another company? If they can do the job you expect them to, following your company's privacy policies, then that's all that matters. Otherwise, their personal moral compass is absolutely none of your business, and it's offensively paternalistic to suggest otherwise.
- mdoms 6y agoIt's unethical to hire people who align with your (and your company's) values?
- crazygringo 6y agoTo only hire such people, or give them preference? Of course it is. This is precisely why hiring for "cultural fit", very often also called "company culture" or "company values", often leads to racial or other discrimination. Because different groups hold different values. E.g. white guys from expensive colleges hiring people who "align with their values" can result in deeply discriminatory behavior -- racially, culturally, socioeconomically, etc. -- even if that's not the intention.
- stale2002 6y ago> Who appointed you moral judge of others? Well, they got appointed the judge of others when they were put in charge of figuring out if it would be a good idea to hire someone for the company. Having moral red flags is a perfectly valid thing for a company to be concerned about. Immoral employees are at risk of doing bad things, and can hurt the company. > based on their moral views unrelated to their work It is pretty related to the work though. It is directly about the moral decisions that they made, while at work. Specifically it would be for working for that company that is doing immoral things.