3 ms·
> To do this, Congress should pass legislation reducing the size of Washington, D.C., to an area encompassing only a few core federal buildings and then admit t
by klyrs 6y ago
> To do this, Congress should pass legislation reducing the size of Washington, D.C., to an area encompassing only a few core federal buildings and then admit the rest of the District’s 127 neighborhoods as states. These states — which could be added with a simple congressional majority — would add enough votes in Congress to ratify four amendments: (1) a transfer of the Senate’s power to a body that represents citizens equally; (2) an expansion of the House so that all citizens are represented in equal-sized districts; (3) a replacement of the Electoral College with a popular vote; and (4) a modification of the Constitution’s amendment process that would ensure future amendments are ratified by states representing most Americans.
I've long believed that city-states would be a good way to remedy unequal representation, but this plan is hamhanded and has some pretty obvious failure modes.
First and most obvious is that civil war is a topic of open discussion, and this would go down like a match in a flour silo. Second is the incredible optimism that the people of these 127 freshly minted states would vote the way they're told, and not, say, rewrite the constitution in a way that cements their supermajority status.
- ryandvm 6y ago> (3) a replacement of the Electoral College with a popular vote Replacing the electoral college with a popular vote is like deciding the World Series based on the total number of runs scored (instead of games won). Sure it's an objective comparison of _something_, but it doesn't necessarily select the winner with the broadest and most consistent support.
- klyrs 6y agoI'm not sure that I understand your sports analogy, but I'm pretty sure that you're comparing a tournament to an election and I'm gonna call that a strike. But anyway, I'm curious what measure you would use to quantify "broadest support" and "most consistent support", and why the current system optimizes those measures better than a simple majority.