3 ms·
This is the obvious reason, but of course there are many more: executions are quite expensive, they don't seem to actually deter crime, they're fundamentally pe
by saagarjha 6y ago
This is the obvious reason, but of course there are many more: executions are quite expensive, they don't seem to actually deter crime, they're fundamentally pessimistic ("this person will never be useful to society"). Plus, they're kind of unnecessarily cruel: if we wanted to execute people painlessly we could just pump a room full of nitrogen and let the person drift off into unconsciousness and death relatively quickly and silently. But for whatever reason we don't do this, instead opting for spectacles of shooting the person or zapping them or injecting slow paralytics into their veins. My personal guess is that people like to watch for some sort of catharsis which a silent death doesn't give them, but of course I'm not necessarily in a position to judge this well.
- BrianOnHN 6y ago> opting for spectacles All while insisting on the humanness of those sweet pharmaceuticals.
- Sebb767 6y ago> this person will never be useful to society I'm against the death penalty, but, since the alternative is most likely life in prison, this is very probably true for rightfully convicted. > My personal guess is that people like to watch for some sort of catharsis which a silent death doesn't give them, but of course I'm not necessarily in a position to judge this well. There's a very interesting documentary called "how to kill a human being". In it, Michael Portillo explores more humane ways to execute prisoners, but at the end his method is rejected by proponents as the do not want these people to die painless. So you're probably not wrong.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI haven't been to prison so I don't know how practical what I'm about to say actually is, but it seems like it's still possible to contribute to society while in prison. e.g. working in the library and helping someone with a shorter term get their GED, or even activism (like how Tookie Williams tried to end the cycle of gang violence that had put him on death row and got half a dozen Nobel Prize nominations before his execution)
- sneak 6y agoI have a personal theory that the correlation between the popularity of religious fundamentalism and the presence of popular support for the death penalty in southern US states has a common underlying cause. There seems to be a certain draw of the Sodom and Gomorrah treatment in some people that draws a straight line from modern day human culture in those places directly back to ancient desert folktales through all these thousands of years. Perhaps it is the belief that actions undertaken in the here-and-now aren't ultimately that important, a sort of cosmic nihilism with regards to the physical reality we live in. We still have so, so far to go.