11 ms·
> He attributes this to the presence of more-infectious variants. I still think facemasks are selecting for more infectious strains and likely won't be effecti
by dehrmann 6y ago
> He attributes this to the presence of more-infectious variants.
I still think facemasks are selecting for more infectious strains and likely won't be effective enough in a few years unless vaccines bring us to herd immunity fast enough or the virus mutates into something less severe.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoFace masks couldn’t be doing that because they don’t work to slow transmission whatsoever. The whole theory of face masks - even before accounting for real world usage - rests on the assumption that the primary transmission mode is respiratory droplets and not aerosols which is not the case. They’re just medical security theater, except worse because they have obvious negatives. I advocate instead for performing rain dances; they’re no less effective but provide a bit of exercise to boot. Anyway, on a related vein, non-infection-protecting vaccines can do exactly what you’re saying and select for more virulent/pathogenic strains. Take a look: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1002198 https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jou.... Because all the COVID/19 vaccines do not prevent infection nor transmission (they reduce it but don’t fully block it), our incredibly shortsighted mass vaccination campaign is likely to select for more pathogenic strains. Go science! > Could some vaccines drive the evolution of more virulent pathogens? Conventional wisdom is that natural selection will remove highly lethal pathogens if host death greatly reduces transmission. Vaccines that keep hosts alive but still allow transmission could thus allow very virulent strains to circulate in a population. Here we show experimentally that immunization of chickens against Marek's disease virus enhances the fitness of more virulent strains, making it possible for hyperpathogenic strains to transmit. Immunity elicited by direct vaccination or by maternal vaccination prolongs host survival but does not prevent infection, viral replication or transmission, thus extending the infectious periods of strains otherwise too lethal to persist. Our data show that anti-disease vaccines that do not prevent transmission can create conditions that promote the emergence of pathogen strains that cause more severe disease in unvaccinated hosts.
- sterlind 6y agowe should be pushing for N95 masks to be cheaper and more available. those masks block aerosols when they're properly fitted (and we should make them easier to fit.)
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoI would love for N95 usage to become more widespread, but that is hampered by the dogmatic clinging to the belief that cloth masks actually work, unfortunately. Do N95s work for source control though? They certainly do work for self infection but I haven’t personally read any N95 studies on source control so am not sure.
- sterlind 6y agothe ones without exhalation valves do. the barrier is bidirectional. the ones with valves bypass this which is why those shouldn't be used for source control but are popular for wildfires etc.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoThanks. That was my thinking but glad to see it confirmed. Kind of ironic that you’re not allowed to wear an N95 with an exhale valve, but are encouraged to wear a surgical mask, bandana, cloth mask, or dirty T-shirt, none of which provide any source control. Again, the elephant in the room is respiratory viruses in general, and SARS-2 in particular, spread via aerosols. Non-N95 face coverings cannot block aerosols. Indeed mask wearing leads to deeper breaths to maintain homeostasis (this has been studied), therefore lead to a greater net volume of air, therefore lead to increased aerosol emission before even accounting for the potential to nebulize large droplets into a shower of tiny aerosol particles. But I digress.
- loosescrews 6y agoA surgical mask, bandana, cloth mask, or dirty T-shirt over a particulate mask (e.g. N95) is typically allowed. There are serious benefits to the wearer to having an exhaust valve. Wearing a second, less effective face covering over the particulate mask retains the benefits of the particulate mask and exhaust valve while maintaining the same level of source control as without the particulate mask.
- Tepix 6y agoWhere are the studies that your base your assumption upon?
- dehrmann 6y agoFair question. We've never done this before to this extent, so there just aren't studies, and this is just a hypothesis. It reminded me a lot of antibiotic resistance, though.
- blackoil 6y agoNone of the virus build resistance to masks. what exactly is the hypothesis? Masks just reduce the transmission rate, so it shouldn't have any correlation with virality. A 10x more viral variant will still be 10x more with masks, just that overall transmission for all variants will be reduced by 90%
- penteract 6y agoI've had thoughts on similar lines to the top level comment, by the following line of reasoning: In US and Europe, policies and behavior (such as mask-wearing and social distancing) have become stricter as the number of cases rise and more lenient as the number of cases fall. This means that the reproduction number hovers around 1. If we imagine that R_0 for Covid-19 is 2.0, no measures are taken, and a variant which is twice as infectious appears when there are 10^6 cases (in a population of 10^9), then the variant will have only infected ~10^6 people by the time we have herd immunity (a very rough estimate). On the other hand, if measures halving the spread rate are imposed when 10^6 cases are reached and the variant appears, then the variant will still spread exponentially while the original strain is curtailed, resulting in most people catching the highly infectious variant. I have no background in medicine or epidemiology, so I'm keen for people to point out flaws. Edit: I am not advocating that no measures to stop or slow the spread of Covid should have been taken.