2 ms·
So I read the whole paper, and not just the abstract. The authors do not conflate caffeine and coffee in the meta-analysis, in fact, they cite several studies t
by heavyset_go 6y ago
So I read the whole paper, and not just the abstract. The authors do not conflate caffeine and coffee in the meta-analysis, in fact, they cite several studies that document the association between coffee consumption and the reduced risk of cognitive decline.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoDid you check whether those studies do this conflation? Were they epidemiological studies (which cannot prove causality), or double-blind randomized studies (which can)?
- codyswann 6y agoI think that burden falls on you since you're the one trying to discredit the study.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoWell, yeah. The studies were all longitudinal studies relying on self-reporting and some found an increased risk for >5 cups per day. Since a ”cup” is not a well defined measurement anyway, these are not very rigorous studies. It’s baffling that scientists so readily interpret these results to mean something, when it’s infinitely more likely they’ve missed some unexpected confounders. I found no mention of MAO inhibitors, beta-carbolines or heterocyclic aromatic amines in coffee. The authors seem to be unaware of their existence, even though they could explain the results in many ways.