4 ms·
This is a thinner argument than I think people realize. That’s like saying “it’s already illegal to kill bald eagles, so it should be legal to sell bald eagle f
by rayiner 6y ago
This is a thinner argument than I think people realize. That’s like saying “it’s already illegal to kill bald eagles, so it should be legal to sell bald eagle feathers.” Sometimes it’s very hard to prosecute some source wrongdoing after the product has entered the steam of commerce, so to speak. We routinely make things illegal at the point where it’s easiest to prosecute, even if doing so incidentally captures some distinguishable conduct.
- sneak 6y agoIt should be legal to sell bald eagle feathers, as well as have any arbitrary sequence of bytes stored in a file on one's disk. I don't see why everyone in society should have to have their liberty arbitrarily restricted just because cops are terrible at their ostensible jobs. It's not that enforcement is hard, it's that legal systems have decided that cops shouldn't have to be any good to do policing, and then they work backward from that. It's the wrong way around. Attacking the leaf nodes of a societal problem lets it look like something is being done by police, when it is actually a huge injustice and a complete waste of time and resources. You could spend billions to bust a million hookers and johns and never once make the tiniest dent in human trafficking.
- dieortin 6y agoIf selling bald eagle feathers is legal, the incentive to kill one is bigger. Now unless you’re caught in the act of killing a bald eagle, there’s nothing they can do.
- sneak 6y agoThere are lots of ways of enforcing laws against people who are not caught in the act. Most convicted of murder are not caught in the act, for example.
- tptacek 6y agoYou're just kind of ignoring Rayiner's argument at this point. We already know that there are people who believe in principle that this stuff shouldn't be prosecuted at all. What's interesting is an argument that manages to engage with what Rayiner is saying; if you can't do that, you might as well just post at the top of the thread instead.
- sneak 6y agoI did that already in my first reply, but the "if you're not caught in the act it's unenforceable" red herring popped up.
- austincheney 6y agoI fail to see how that’s a red herring.
- sneak 6y agoWell, it's factually incorrect for one, as I pointed out in my reply.
- Ericson2314 6y agoFalse equivalence. Unless you want nasty old feathers it's impossible to obtain them without killing the Eagle, but there is sex work without trafficking.
- grawprog 6y ago>it's impossible to obtain them without killing the Eagle I find Eagle feathers pretty regularly in the area around where i live. A bunch of them nest across the street and there's another nest in the back of the yard in an old tree that's been used every year for years now. Some are old and nasty, most are pretty fresh though.
- jfrunyon 6y agoThen it probably should in fact be legal to sell them.
- bluGill 6y agoOnly because it is illegal. Eagles die of natural causes. You still aren't allowed to collect those feathers.
- JamesBarney 6y agoDo you think prostitution is easier to prosecute than kidnapping? It seems like kidnapping would be a far easier to prosecute than prostitution. Also how many kidnapped individuals are we finding in random prostitution stings?
- betwixthewires 6y agoIf bald eagles were capable of willfully selling their own feathers you'd have a point and your analogy would be apt. The biggest hazards to a prostitute is legal repercussion and the secondary effects of that, like having no legal recourse after being abused. That's not "incidentally capturing some distinguishable conduct", the vast majority of dangers associated with this industry are artificially created by unjust laws directly driven by social taboo of a few.
- austincheney 6y agoLikewise your comment is only valid so long as all participants are willing and voluntary. Legalization doesn’t not address that concern.
- sneak 6y agoIt does, as anyone forced into prostitution without consent could then seek standard legal remedies for things like kidnapping/battery/coercion/etc. So long as it remains illegal, that's basically impossible.
- austincheney 6y agoSo by that logic legalizing child pornography and child prostitution would eliminate the harms associated with those. I am going to disagree with that, not only because its baseless, but also because its absurd.
- novok 6y agoChildren are not adults and so cannot sexually consent is the basis of most laws that prevent that.
- austincheney 6y agoAgreed. Legalization is not a cure all.
- jfrunyon 6y ago"We should ban hunting, because it's very hard to prosecute poaching after the product has entered the st[r]eam of commerce" wonder how well that would go over here in the US. And yet it's perfectly good logic when it agrees with the decisions you've already made.
- austincheney 6y agoActually, it is legal precedent. Game wardens are the only law enforcement officers in the US that do not require search warrants because in their line of work everything is an exigency exception to the 4th amendment.
- jfrunyon 6y agoIt's not nearly that simple. That's also not a ban on a downstream activity, like a ban on prostitution is.