6 ms·
Kidnapping is already illegal. There's nothing about legal prostitution that prevents enforcement of the myriad of existing laws prohibiting kidnapping, batter
by sneak 6y ago
Kidnapping is already illegal.
There's nothing about legal prostitution that prevents enforcement of the myriad of existing laws prohibiting kidnapping, battery, and robbery associated with human trafficking.
- austincheney 6y agoHuman trafficking is different than kidnapping. The former is the forced distribution of persons for criminal acts while the later is the act of taking persons against their will.
- sneak 6y ago"forced distribution" is the same thing.
- austincheney 6y agoIt’s not the same. Kidnapping is an illegal act but not a form of slavery while human trafficking is. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_trafficking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_trafficking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_to_Prevent,_Suppress_and_Punish_Trafficking_in_Persons,_Especially_Women_and_Children https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_to_Prevent,_Suppres...
- Ericson2314 6y agoThis is not important. That sort of slavery is easy to deam legal without getting into what the forced work is. Sex work = trafficking is, best case, a misplaced utopianism that makes things worse here and now, and often a far worse patronizing moralistic sexism.
- austincheney 6y agoThat is not what I said.
- toolz 6y agoYou can't traffick humans without kidnapping them and holding them against their will. The whole point is we already have laws on the books to prevent that regardless of whether prostitution is legal or not.
- austincheney 6y agoIn the case of people most jurisdictions want more severe laws in place than possession of stole goods against those people who are holding others against their will but did not kidnap them, as in they received the victims from others who may or may not have taken them by force.
- toolz 6y agoaggravated kidnapping in the US often gets 20 years in jail. median sentence for murder is 13 years. I can imagine you might think the sentence would be lighter but there's nothing preventing heavy sentencing for kidnapping. edit: holding a human captive even if you aren't the original captor is still kidnapping so that detail doesn't really change anything
- jfoutz 6y agoUsually ambulances can speed, for example.
- rayiner 6y agoThis is a thinner argument than I think people realize. That’s like saying “it’s already illegal to kill bald eagles, so it should be legal to sell bald eagle feathers.” Sometimes it’s very hard to prosecute some source wrongdoing after the product has entered the steam of commerce, so to speak. We routinely make things illegal at the point where it’s easiest to prosecute, even if doing so incidentally captures some distinguishable conduct.
- sneak 6y agoIt should be legal to sell bald eagle feathers, as well as have any arbitrary sequence of bytes stored in a file on one's disk. I don't see why everyone in society should have to have their liberty arbitrarily restricted just because cops are terrible at their ostensible jobs. It's not that enforcement is hard, it's that legal systems have decided that cops shouldn't have to be any good to do policing, and then they work backward from that. It's the wrong way around. Attacking the leaf nodes of a societal problem lets it look like something is being done by police, when it is actually a huge injustice and a complete waste of time and resources. You could spend billions to bust a million hookers and johns and never once make the tiniest dent in human trafficking.
- dieortin 6y agoIf selling bald eagle feathers is legal, the incentive to kill one is bigger. Now unless you’re caught in the act of killing a bald eagle, there’s nothing they can do.
- sneak 6y agoThere are lots of ways of enforcing laws against people who are not caught in the act. Most convicted of murder are not caught in the act, for example.
- tptacek 6y agoYou're just kind of ignoring Rayiner's argument at this point. We already know that there are people who believe in principle that this stuff shouldn't be prosecuted at all. What's interesting is an argument that manages to engage with what Rayiner is saying; if you can't do that, you might as well just post at the top of the thread instead.