3 ms·
I found these statements by the associate department head interesting: https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384955467051454466 https://twitter.com/lorenter
by detaro 6y ago
I found these statements by the associate department head interesting:
https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384955467051454466 https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384955467051454466
> I do work in Social Computing, and this situation is directly analogous to a number of incidents on Wikipedia quite awhile ago that led to that community and researchers reaching an understanding on research methods that are and are not acceptable.
and https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384966202301337603 https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384966202301337603
> Yes! This was an IRB 'failure'. Again, in my area of Social Computing, it's been clear for awhile that IRBs often do not understand the issues and the potential risks/harms of doing research in online communities / social media.
An interesting question is IMHO who people actually tried to contact in the first round of this getting publicity (and I guess how many did so at all), and if leadership should thus have been aware earlier that there was controversy worth looking into.
- fhars 6y agoThat whole twitter thread is really interesting, starting from https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384954220705722369 https://twitter.com/lorenterveen/status/1384954220705722369
- detaro 6y agoYes Twitter is "weird" about with sub-thread it picks as the "main" one (well, it choses one and didn't pick the interesting one here), so I had to explicitly link the latter point.
- debaserab2 6y agoYeah, it gets even worse: https://twitter.com/SarahJamieLewis/status/1384871385537908736 https://twitter.com/SarahJamieLewis/status/13848713855379087...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alisonkisk 6y agoThat's shameful of the IEEE committee that approved the paper.
- the_snooze 6y agoAbsolutely. I think this is more of a failure of the IEEE Security and Privacy program committee (PC) than that of the university. The chairs should have desk rejected it on ethical grounds. Failing that, at least one of the reviewers should have noticed this was fishy and raised the alarm. And failing that, someone in the full PC meeting should have been like "whoa, hol up." (though this last failure could be partially explained with PC meetings now happening online instead of in person, so less engagement)
- CaffeineSqurr 6y agoTerveen was always honest about what works and what doesn't work. Its good to see them acknowledge that this is something they need to dive into and fix.
- finnthehuman 6y ago>it's been clear for awhile that IRBs often do not understand the issues and the potential risks/harms of doing research in online communities / social media. Too bad he's not in a position of power to implement that additional review to CS department research.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zenir 6y agoBasically now they can do a meta study on how the review process of IRB has flaws. As shown, if you intentionally try to bypass the IRB, apparently you can. It's even reproducible.
- xwolfi 6y agoOh so interesting ! In my french uni, psych teachers were all doing wikipedia research to prove it was unreliable by timing correction delay of purposedly introduced mistakes, They were so proud of their discovery. They didnt think to time what that would take if they went to a printer and changed the text there before a book is printed.
- azernik 6y agoNote from the reader: said associate department head, Loren Terveen, is one of the two signers of the CS&E statement.