5 ms·
Sadly I suspect the people in law enforcement who make purchasing decisions never read the Signal blog, and therefore all these points will be moot.
by londons_explore 6y ago
Sadly I suspect the people in law enforcement who make purchasing decisions never read the Signal blog, and therefore all these points will be moot.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThey don't have to read that. The defense lawyers have to read it, and the people in law enforcement need to read the cases where judges throw out Cellebrite evidence based on that.
- waltwalther 6y agoThis.
- nvr219 6y agoThe worst enterprises using Cellebrite don't really have to worry about defense lawyers.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoNo, but Cellebrite does because their credibility is what sells their products to law enforcement. It wouldn't kill all their sales, but enough to be painful.
- psd1 6y agoIf you, as I do, hold that personal devices should be private, then you're probably happy with the extraction tools being weak. Let them remain complacent.
- syshum 6y agoThe problem with that is the cases would need to get to the discovery stage. 95% of all criminal cases in the US are Plead out largely because the defendant can not afford competent legal representation This is why all kinds of questionable investigative tactics are still used even some that have clearly been ruled unconstitutional, they know most of the time it will not matter, they just need to get enough to make an arrest, the system will destroy the person anyway no conviction needed, and most likely the person will plead guilty even if innocent just to make the abuse stop
- z77dj3kl 6y agoDo all defendants not have the right to an attorney in criminal cases? If evidence is obviously (or with high chance) disputable, then it puts pressure even in those cases where the attorney recommends the defendant to eventually plead. Or maybe the attorneys available to those who can't afford are just crap in general?
- syshum 6y ago>>Do all defendants not have the right to an attorney in criminal cases? In theory yes, but in most cases that will be a overworked lawyer that has 100's or 1000's of other active cases, and will not spend time other than negotiation the best deal. Even if you happen to get a good public defender that has the ability to devote lots of time to your individual case, they would have no budget to hire an expert witness to present the vulnerabilities in the Cell-bright software to a jury Your best bet would be if the ACLU or EFF took an interest in your case, but they take on very few cases relatively speaking and tend to focus on precedent setting cases, or cases that have high public interest (or can be made to have high public interest) >Or maybe the attorneys available to those who can't afford are just crap in general? In some cases they are incompetent, however in most cases they are just underfunded and massively over worked. In most jurisdictions the public defenders office is funded is 1/10 or less of what the prosecutors office is funded at.
- wglb 6y agoThat won't do much. In order to throw the evidence out, it needs to be shown that something was actually compromised by the tool, not just that it is possible. Consider https://www.securityweek.com/forensics-tool-flaw-allows-hackers-manipulate-evidence#:~:text=A%20vulnerability%20in%20Guidance%20Software's,the%20flaw%20any%20time%20soon https://www.securityweek.com/forensics-tool-flaw-allows-hack.... Have any cases been thrown out? I don't think so.
- jjoonathan 6y agoThey won't be moot when defense lawyers bring them up.
- londons_explore 6y agoDoesn't matter. When you can go through every message on someones phone back for years, I'm sure you can find something to put nearly anyone in prison for. No need to tell the court how you found out about the lawnmowing for the neighbour that was never reported to the IRS...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- filmgirlcw 6y agoWhen you can call into question the data integrity of the items on the device and whether the information from that device is accurate or was inserted by the machine used to break into it, that is some very basic fourth amendment stuff that could possibly get all items taken from the device deemed inadmissible.
- neodymiumphish 6y agoEh, this goes two ways. Cellebrite is rarely going to result in the only meaningful evidence that proves a single element of the offense. Instead, it is often used to further an investigation in order to find evidence that is more damning and of a higher evidentiary value. Fortunately for law enforcement, the integrity of the Cellebrite-obtained data is all that important if it leads to further evidence that is more significant.
- kstrauser 6y agoI don’t think that’s true. There’s a legal idea of “fruit of the poisonous tree”[0] that basically says you can’t use bad evidence, either in court or as an excuse to collect more, valid evidence. The defense attorney would say “if it hadn’t been for that completely untrustworthy Cellebrite evidence, the police wouldn’t have been able to get that search warrant they used to find the gun at his house, so we want that thrown out.” And the judge would probably go along with that, and if they don’t an appeals court probably would. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Hnrobert42 6y agoThey, and the people who support them, do. Moreover, not all of their users are involved in ethically questionable activity. Many of them are scrupulously following due process to thwart people doing really bad things.
- malka 6y agoGood. They will then collect useless data that a lawyer will destroy in court.