4 ms·
I think so. With a large project I think a realist attitude that raises to the level of mean when there’s bullshit around is somewhat necessary to prevent deca
by colechristensen 6y ago
I think so. With a large project I think a realist attitude that raises to the level of mean when there’s bullshit around is somewhat necessary to prevent decay.
If not you get cluttered up with bad code and people there for the experience. Like how stackoverflow is lost to rule zealots there for the game not for the purpose.
Something big and important should be intimidating and isn’t a public service babysitter...
- ethbr0 6y agoIt feels like a corollary of memetic assholery in online communities. Essentially the R0 [0] of being a dick. If I have a community, bombarded by a random number of transient bad actors at random times, then if R0 > some threshold, my community inevitably trends to a cesspool, as each bad actor creates more negative members. If I take steps to decrease R0, one of which may indeed be "blunt- and harshness to new contributors", then my community may survive in the face of equivalent pressures. It's a valid point, and seems to have historical support via evidence of many egalitarian / welcoming communities collapsing due to the accumulation of bad faith participants. The key distinction is probably "Are you being blunt / harsh in the service of the primary goal, or ancillary to the mission?" [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number
- depressedpanda 6y ago> It's a valid point, and seems to have historical support via evidence of many egalitarian / welcoming communities collapsing due to the accumulation of bad faith participants. Could you provide references to some of this historical support?
- yifanl 6y agoKinda a silly example, but several subreddits that started out with the aim of making fun of some subject (i.e. r/prequelmemes and the Star Wars prequels, or r/the_donald and then Presidential candidate Donald Trump) were quickly turned into communities earnestly supporting the initial subject of parody.
- alexeldeib 6y agoI don't think this is silly at all. And the fact that reddit's admins occasionally have to step in with a forceful hand over what the mods do only speaks louder to GP's point.
- ethbr0 6y agoI think Reddit is the broadest example, because it's evidence of both outcomes due to the diversity in moderation policy between subs. Some can tolerate a steady influx of bad actors: some fall apart. There's probably a valid paper in there somewhere.
- tester756 6y ago> Like how stackoverflow is lost to rule zealots there for the game not for the purpose. Like?
- skeletal88 6y agoHonest questions getting downvoted, closed for being too broad, duplicates or just "Wrong" in the eyes of overzealous long time members
- tester756 6y agoThere's nothing wrong with duplicates If they weren't doing it, then quality of SO would decrease for all of us. It's in our interest to have strict mods on SO
- burnished 6y agoYou haven't seen a question closed as a duplicate when it was clear that time or details had made the linked question not an actual duplicate?
- JadeNB 6y agoI think the idea is that it's better to err on the side of too-strict moderation than too-lax. People can always come back to re-try a question at another time, but, once the spirit of the community is lost, there's not much you can do about it. (Not to say I like the StackExchange community much. It's far too top-down directed for me. But I'm very much sympathetic to the spirit of strict moderation.)
- burnished 6y agoI agree with you. Its silly to act like the phenomenon doesn't exist though.
- threatofrain 6y ago
- admax88q 6y agoI'm not sure why you think you have to be mean to avoid bad code. Being nice doesn't mean accepting any and all contributions. It just means not being a jerk or _overly_ harsh when rejecting.
- ABCLAW 6y agoYou can create a strict, high functioning organization without being an asshole. Maintaining high standards and expecting excellence isn't an exercise in babysitting; it's an exercise in aligning contributors to those same standards and expectations. You don't need to do that by telling them they're garbage. You can do it by getting them invested in growth and improvement.
- da_big_ghey 6y agothat is depend on who you are asking. if i am taking "no nonsense" aproach then some people are having no problem. but other people, include especialy woman, are say that it is not "nice" and that there is some problem even if it is neither "mean". also here we are seeing persons are having no interest in "growth and improvement", they are not even creating the good faith contributions to project.