5 ms·
If the "machine" somehow continued to work fine with him not being there for 15 years, why did his position even exist? The investigation and article focuses t
by Nextgrid 6y ago
If the "machine" somehow continued to work fine with him not being there for 15 years, why did his position even exist?
The investigation and article focuses too much on "attendance" instead of measuring real work and raising the question as to which other positions are actually useless?
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>If the "machine" somehow continued to work fine with him not being there for 15 years, why did his position even exist? Tons of paper pushing positions exist so that politicians and high level appointed bureaucrats can do favors for people whom they owe favors. Someone (like the deadbeat brother of someone who donated to the governor's campaign or whatever, just making up a reasonable example) who could never hold such a well paying job on their own merits will be given a job and as long as they continue to punch the clock (though per TFA that's not a hard requirement in Italy) the will continue to get paid.
- slumdev 6y agoThese positions are sometimes called "patronage" jobs. The Vice President launched her career with a position like this, which she received from her married boyfriend, Willie Brown. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/politics/kamala-harris-launched-political-career-with-120k-patronage-job-from-boyfriend-willie-brown https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/politics/kamala-harris-la... > Granlund said the appointment seemed brazen at the time because of the relationship between Harris and Brown. “Screwing the speaker has its rewards,” he said. “Stevie Wonder could have seen through that play.”
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI think there's a big difference between sucking your way to the front of the line of qualified applicants for a legitimate job vs jobs that exist simply to be given out for patronage purposes. IMO getting a job by pulling strings isn't as morally dirty as a job existing for no reason other than to transfer money from the taxpayer to someone with connections.
- baremetal 6y agoSounds like the words of a man on the receiving end of said suck
- dominotw 6y agobecause the machine not driven by checks and balances enforced by investors. I grew up in a socialist country and this type of stuff was the default and not something newsworthy at all. Everyone did it. All the dads in my residential unit would go sign the attendance sheet and come back home by 11 am and have rest of the day to themselves to garden, grow food, take a nap, play cards ect. How do proponents of govt run services and production units address this core flaw. I've asked many people but have never gotten a good response.
- tankenmate 6y agoIncompetence is incompetence, regardless of its source. And re: the investors, don't governments issue bonds? i.e. all governments that issue bonds have investors.
- dmos62 6y agoI'd go further and say everyone owns bonds in the common good. Private organizations don't have a monopoly on interdependence, or public ones on incompetence.
- mavhc 6y agoWhen running a government department there's no way to become more powerful except by getting more people. If you run your department efficiently you don't get to expand and take over other markets, instead you'd lose employees under your command and get a smaller budget, the incentives are wrong
- andrew_v4 6y agoThis is spot on. I have worked as a consultant doing reviews of a handful of diverse government departments, and leadership's priorities were always identical: justify headcount increases. Every one will have a presentation about the changing nature of their work, new legislation, the decline in staff vs some past golden age etc etc that shows they need more people. As you say, its 100% a function of the incentives. This is a general flaw with "command" economies where resources are based on who can argue for them best as opposed to demand for the outputs. There is a lot that can be done in terms of SLAs for operational departments and discretion to the operational side on how money gets spent, to try and come closer to a market driven system, but there is no political will for it.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoWelcome to government work.
- fbhabbed 6y agoThe thing is, the machine barely works. Most hospitals here claim to be understaffed, the queues are immense and this despite healthcare financing being at an all time high. I suspect this sort of frauds are way more widespread than people realize