9 ms·
you really think having a civil war right around the corner, practically on the other side of the fence, is something any country wants to have? not to mention
by baq 6y ago
you really think having a civil war right around the corner, practically on the other side of the fence, is something any country wants to have? not to mention having an armed rebellion means putin's intervention is guaranteed and then belarus just becomes another federal district.
- baybal2 6y ago> you really think having a civil war right around the corner, practically on the other side of the fence, is something any country wants to have? If you don't want a civil war on the other side of the fence, go and win it. With current discord in the Belorussian armed forces, double digit desertion rate, broken command chain, even the smallest NATO armies can easily plough though them. Your bigger problem will be the militarised special police, paramilitaries, and secret services, which are in fact, bigger, and better armed, and trained than the standing military (this is the same situation you have across all Eastern Bloc btw.)
- baq 6y agoi'm sure all Belarusans would love to have two foreign armies marching through their homeland, both with words of liberation on their standards.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agothis argument is akin to somebody just having kidnapped my family while despite me knowing where the kidnappers live being told I should not gun up but "come up with a peaceful plan" (perhaps hit the kidnappers with a leaflet campaign).
- La1n 6y agoExcept in this case it's not "your family". People here are arguing for foreign intervention. Not everything that happens in another country you don't agree with should be solved with violent foreign intervention...
- buran77 6y agoThat's exactly what a hostage rescue should be like until there's no other option: negotiations, the peaceful plan. So you know where the kidnappers live? You grab your shotgun to get them "Rambo style". Best case only the kidnappers get injured or killed. Worst case you and your family get killed. It feels like too many people simply cannot go past the basic reaction "I find it may be a threat > shoot to kill". I find this a failure in education. And while it may turn out at some point that for Belarus there was simply no other option, it still doesn't justify jumping straight to it. Just a bit of common sense can already tell you that the most likely outcome is that civilians will get killed by the thousands and this time it will be "justified" as defending against acts of war. Guns escalate everything. They may escalate your power but they also escalate the response.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agothat's a bad-faith argument, it should instead be: Do you really want to allow systematic killing of the opposition by current un-elected criminals holding on to power. Putin's intervention is not some kind of "hypothetical future danger or milestone in theoretic escalation" but has been fact since 1998. Europe isn't going to do anything except sending their thoughts and prayers and direct intervention by the US is unthinkable (for now). Sending support (which includes arms, and mercenaries) is the only way that can protect the civilian population. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belarus%E2%80%93Russia_relations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belarus%E2%80%93Russia_relatio...
- ceilingcorner 6y agoNo, starting a civil war is exactly the wrong thing to do if you want to protect the civilian population.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agothat's pretty hyperbolic. it's not "starting a civil war" it's leveling the playing field against those who are already brutalizing the population.
- baybal2 6y agoYou don't protect civilians by letting a mad genocidal regime mow down unarmed people with machineguns. The civil war is already de-facto going. People who tell to do nothing make peoples' of Belarus suffer in agony for longer. Look at Yugoslavia. You would've been still seeing Milosevic's smiling face from TV if not NATO, and EU not only arming Bosnians, but forcing the conflict, and bringing it to a boiling point. Only then the crazed genocidal generals started to actually feel... fear. And it was it what allowed for a relatively bloodless ouster of Milosevic in 97.