3 ms·
People did. That is largely a matter of scale. Woodstoves are not widely used in major habitated areas (cities and suburbs) in advanced countries. They're a
by dredmorbius 6y ago
People did. That is largely a matter of scale.
Woodstoves are not widely used in major habitated areas (cities and suburbs) in advanced countries. They're a primary heating source principally in rural areas, where population is sparse. Or, of course, in developing countries where other heating options aren't available.
When woodfuel was a principle fuel source, forests were indeed being cut down faster than they could regrow just to provide fuel. And some of the oldest enviromental regulations and restrictions in the world address the sustenance and conservation of woodlands. The aphorism that "forests preceed mankind, deserts follow" has a great deal of truth to it. It was exhaustion of fuelwood throughout Great Britain, Ireland, and mainland Europe that lead to the adoption of coal, and the burning of coal which largely lead to the resurgence of European forests.
In developing countries, fuel avaiability and woodstove (or other solid fuel, often animal droppings) particulate emissions are major energy security and health concerns.
At small scale, and for occasional use, in areas with abundant tree growth, fuelwood is viable. Given present human population densities, at a large scale, it is not.
- eliaspro 6y ago> Woodstoves are not widely used in major habitated areas (cities and suburbs) in advanced countries. They're a primary heating source principally in rural areas, where population is sparse. Or, of course, in developing countries where other heating options aren't available. Unfortunately, that's not the case for large parts of Western Europe, where wood-based heating is considered eco-friendly, due to it being classified as "renewable". For example. in Germany you'll get 40% of a wood-pellet burner subsidized. Many villages and also towns are plagued by heavy air pollution. Emissions from those by now have surpassed those by cars, according to the German federal environmental agency. [1] Scientific findings and political action don't match up at all here - some other European countries slowly start to address this issue, but then again UK is pushing for the Drax power plant which runs exclusively on wood pellets whose wood sources are highly problematic [2]. [1] https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/daten/luft/emissionsminderung-bei-kleinfeuerungsanlagen https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/daten/luft/emissionsminderung... [2] https://www.biofuelwatch.org.uk/2021/draxs-pinewells-case-study/ https://www.biofuelwatch.org.uk/2021/draxs-pinewells-case-st...
- dredmorbius 6y agoI'm not contesting that fuelwood isn't a major particulate pollution source, where and when used. I'm contesting that it's widely used. Wood / pellet stoves in dense urban environments are a small fraction of total cooking and heating load. And I'm also arguing precisely your point: that woodstoves widely used are a major pollution and deforestation issue.