3 ms·
Is “Baumol’s cost disease” just a fancy term for the effects of supply and demand in the labor market? I do not see how it is anything more than a trivial resu
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
Is “Baumol’s cost disease” just a fancy term for the effects of supply and demand in the labor market? I do not see how it is anything more than a trivial result of supply and demand and why it merits a special name.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoMany important, ground-breaking concepts seem obvious in retrospect. I doubt that if you surveyed a random selection of economists from the 1950s, they would have been able to describe the phenomenon.
- tuatoru 6y agoIt's intended to capture the idea that wages rise in an industry despite per-employee output not rising, which is against the "marginal wage equals marginal production" basis of classical Marshallian economics. Ironically, given the examples in the article, Baumol's example of cost disease was musicians.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> against the "marginal wage equals marginal production" basis of classical Marshallian economics. I am not aware of Marshallian economics, but I was under the impression that prices (wages) moved along supply and demand curves, and do not have anything to do with production.
- notacoward 6y ago> do not have anything to do with production So concepts like efficiency and elasticity don't matter? The supply and demand curves for different goods and services varyfor specific reasons. Those reasons are worth studying, and sometimes naming.
- thedufer 6y agoThere are different ways of figuring out what a wage will end up being, and looking at how they interact (which is what Baumol's Cost Disease does) can be tricky but enlightening. Supply/demand is one such way. Another is related to elasticity. If a given job can produce $1.00 of value but the next person qualified for that job only expects $.90, someone should be expected to create that job and capture the surplus. And this should continue until the value produced by the next such job is right at the value produced by that job. So you often expect that the wage of a job should be the value produced by that job, at least at the margin. Baumol's Cost Disease shows how when one job's value increases, the wage in jobs that require similar skills can see a growth in wages beyond the degree to which it's value increases - that is, the first job following the model described above causes another job to stop following that model and instead be lifted into a supply/demand model.
- notacoward 6y agoWhy deny credit? Plenty of economists before Baumol (and not a few after) failed to appreciate this phenomenon. As the name suggests, it's a phenomenon about cost moderating the effects of supply and demand, and it's clearly not a trivial result of analysis involving only those two. It's worth understanding in its own right, and AFAIK is typically taught for that reason in Econ 102.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoFrom Wikipedia: > Baumol's cost disease (or the Baumol effect) is the rise of salaries in jobs that have experienced no or low increase of labor productivity, in response to rising salaries in other jobs that have experienced higher labor productivity growth. To me, this seems like the same as 1) the supply of people willing to provide labor x at price y is reduced because the same people have an opportunity to provide labor z at a price > y. 2) supply of people willing to provide labor x for price y is reduced, therefore buyers have to pay a price > y for the same amount of labor x I do not understand what makes this a surprising phenomenon or which “cost” is moderating the effects of supply and demand. People have better opportunities, therefore supply of labor is decreased, therefore assuming if demand does not go down proportionally, then prices will rise. For some jobs, demand will not keep up with the rising price and the number of jobs will greatly decrease or cease to exist, such as horse buggy drivers.
- notacoward 6y agoYou're missing a step. Workers didn't have an opportunity to provide labor Z by random chance. They had that opportunity for a specific reason: greater efficiency gains (i.e. reduced cost per unit of production) in Z than in X. In other words, something about another profession affects wages in X. This is different than intrinsic changes in X, requiring analysis beyond supply and demand for X. Somebody had to look at this phenomenon from outside that narrow micro-economic perspective before it became "obvious" (only in retrospect) to others. That happened to be Baumol and Bowen. Why not use one of their names as a convenient handle for a concept they studied and brought to others' attention? We give "fancy" names to algorithms and even whole systems in computing too, even when their details can be similarly derived from first principles. Do you think we should shun those in favor of purely descriptive names as well?
- dwaltrip 6y agoIt is a specific instance of supply and demand dynamics that may not be immediately obvious. Names are very efficient pointers / handles for concepts. It seems like a useful term to me.