2 ms·
This short article is somewhat misleading on Facebook's position. They are against scraping. Not on behalf of users but on behalf of mass user data collecters
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
This short article is somewhat misleading on Facebook's position. They are against scraping. Not on behalf of users but on behalf of mass user data collecters, what it calls "the industry", like itself. That is why they engage is "anti-scraping". That is also why LinkedIn has tried to sue others for scraping LinkedIn public data.
Facebook does not want the public, outside of "the industry", to have the same public data that Facebook has collected. If everyone can potentially have the same data Facebook has, data collection potentially becomes democratised and the world does not need Facebook nor "the industry" anymore. These advertising services companies no longer have any special value.
The problem with Facebook, and "the industry", is data collection, not lack of "anti-scraping" competence. Once the sensitive data is collected by private industry on a massive scale, then liability is created. The data is not any safer than if a government had collected it. In some jurisdictions it is less safe, because there are restrictions on this type of activity by government that do not apply to companies. This liability is why some people take the position that the data collection Google or Facebook does to further its "business" is neither harmless nor "acceptable".
Facebook is framing this liability problem as one of "scraping", not collection. It is not trying to further the interests of users but instead to further its own interests. Facebook wants the courts and regulatory authorities to see mass quantities of public data about internet users as Facebook's semi-exclusive asset, to be protected as if it was "private" data. Facebook is arguing mass public data "leaks" are not acceptable and that's why "the industry" must step up its "anti-scraping" measures.
However "scraping" the internet for public data is not the problem, it is only a symptom. Massive data collection initiated by these companies about internet users, for the purpose of selling advertising services, is the problem.