6 ms·
I agree with the substance of what you said, but I'm going to nitpick a bit of wording: what you call "developer freedom" isn't freedom at all, and is more righ
by josephcsible 6y ago
I agree with the substance of what you said, but I'm going to nitpick a bit of wording: what you call "developer freedom" isn't freedom at all, and is more rightly called power.
http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/freedom-or-power.en.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/freedom-or-power.en.html
- spoonjim 6y agoArguing over which one is “freedom” is a petty exercise in trying to claim the moral high ground. Instead, it’s more objective and accurate to say that GPL and BSD represent two different ideologies, and that the AGPL is definitely designed to promulgate the “GPL” ideology, so that it’s inability to be incorporated into BSD-licensed software is a feature and not a bug from the perspective of the people who choose to license their code as AGPL.
- quadrangle 6y agoI think you misunderstand the GPL ideology (to use your words). The idealogy is that proprietary software is wrong, bad, unethical. Software freedom should be available to all. The copyleft terms of the GPL are a tactic a means to defending software freedom. And to that extent, all the incompatibility with other free licenses are indeed a bug a downside, a hampering of freedom in practice. That downside is accepted because of (and only when it is) the judgment that it is a net gain for software freedom anyway because it frustrates the development of non-free software. There does not exist any ideology that wants incompatibility between free software licenses. It is a price that some feel should be paid sometimes in order to be incompatible with non-free licenses which are the actual problem.
- m4rtink 6y agoWell, GPL is about freedom for the users, not necessarily for the developers.
- goodpoint 6y agoEvery developer is also an user. And "user" freedom is more important because we use tenths of millions of SLOC and do development work on a small fraction.
- tremon 6y agoThe copyright holder is never a user in a discussion about distribution rights, though.
- goodpoint 6y ago...in a very narrow sense where one person or organization owns all the copyright on a codebase. This can be true for a small program on a microcontroller, but 99.9% of FOSS is deployed as part of a big ecosystem. For each line of code I deploy on production there's 1000 lines of kernel, libraries, daemons, firmware. As developers, we are 0.1% developers and 99.9% users.
- moron4hire 6y agoHow does freedom for the user-who-is-not-a-developer to change the source work, then? The FSF fundamentally assumes the user is a developer. Hell, look at the vast majority of the GNU software. I wouldn't say it's at all targeted at not-developer users.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoThe user could hire any developer, he doesn't have to live within the original author's roadmap.
- clusterfish 6y agoThat seems like splitting hairs for ideological gain. You might as well describe freedom of movement as power to take someone else's job in another town, or freedom of speech as power to manipulate masses, or freedom to do an abortion as power over the unborn child. Which way the issues are framed says more about the author than the issue. Software has leverage (one developer, many users at low marginal cost) built-in, but that doesn't make developing non-(A)GPL or even proprietory software a projection of developer's power. Lack of competition is what lets developer's exert power over users, and while copyleft licenses help with that, they're neither required nor sufficient to prevent abuse of power. At the same time, copyleft doesn't come free (ha), as developers who need to earn a living will choose to work on problems where they can actually extract some profit to compensate for their effort. Not everyone is keen to work for free, or work as much / as hard for free as they would if they could make a living off it. So yes you might get free-er software, but less of it.
- crazypython 6y ago> freedom of movement as power to take someone else's job in another town Freedom of movement is the power to exchange goods and services with anyone. > freedom of speech as power to manipulate masses Freedom of speech is only a freedom if it is accompanied by a potential hearer's freedom to block speech. Modern platforms do not let you choose what or who you want to hear. Freedom of speech without freedom to choose your censor is anarchy. > Lack of competition is what lets developer's exert power over users, and while copyleft licenses help with that, they're neither required nor sufficient to prevent abuse of power. You are ignoring the freedom to modify/fork, plus the requirement of free documentation.
- clusterfish 6y agoQuite a quantum leap there from proprietary licenses to "modern platforms". You're free not to use Facebook, Twitter, et al, you know. There are other, open, platforms. And other closed ones that are decent. Use any of them if you want more control over what you read. Don't fucking shame people for earning money writing good software. Most of us aren't building evil monopolies.
- 6y ago