5 ms·
> Always requiring the modified code be available would make it a license violation to download an AGPL work, change one file, and then delete it because you're
by kelnos 6y ago
> Always requiring the modified code be available would make it a license violation to download an AGPL work, change one file, and then delete it because you're bored.
Right, but you don't have to require that (you can close the "transitive distribution loophole" by explicitly calling it out), and a clause like this would not be enforceable anyway, because all of this relies on copyright law, which is fundamentally about distribution. If there is no distribution, then the license terms do not apply.
IANAL, though, and this is where it gets dicey for me: can you really legally frame "putting software on a server that others can access through an API" as "distribution"? Or does that part not rely on distribution at all, making the AGPL sort of a combo copyright license and EULA?
- kemitchell 6y agoCopyright law is not just distribution. Read 17 U.S.C. §106.
- kelnos 6y agoI'm well aware, and I've read it before. (1) is immaterial to the discussion; I can copy to my heart's content in private, and as long as I don't distribute it, no one will know, and no one will take any action against me. At any rate, fair use defenses #1 and #4[0] are pretty compelling to cover private, non-distributive copying. (2) is similar to (1) in that it has no teeth until you try to distribute your derivative work. (3) is explicitly about distribution. (4) & (5) & (6) are about public display/performance, which don't apply to software, and I would argue are also about distribution anyway. [0] https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/ https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/
- kemitchell 6y agoCourts enforce the rights independently. You can bring a claim under any of them. I'm not aware of any law that you must also claim distribution. Reproduction is inherent in execution, development, etc. on computers. See "licensed, not sold" and the analysis of the ways 117 differs from the CONTU rec.