4 ms·
The main advantage to Disqus (and other hosted solutions) is that their spam protection applies across all comment sections. You'll never get that with an open
by jedberg 6y ago
The main advantage to Disqus (and other hosted solutions) is that their spam protection applies across all comment sections. You'll never get that with an open source solution.
- j3th9n 6y agoI can imagine implementing reCAPTCHA can prevent a lot of spam.
- jedberg 6y agoSadly not anymore. There are click farms in third world countries that will solve 10 captchas for a penny. Not to mention how many people will just not leave a comment if presented with a captcha.
- j3th9n 6y agoI see, I was thinking about reCAPTCHA v3, working invisible in the background.
- tyingq 6y agoUnsurprisingly, there are services for that now that provide a guaranteed minimum score.
- chrismorgan 6y agoreCAPTCHA v3 just gives you a score, and you have to decide what to do with it. This means that you should never under any circumstances use reCAPTCHA v3 as a gate with no alternative—otherwise you will certainly be preventing real users from using the system with no recourse, which will regularly have at least theoretically dire legal consequences. Also, I get the impression that reCAPTCHA v3 is waaaaay less smart than people think. At a small scale, it’s near trivial to tweak your browser so it’ll give scores at opposite ends of the spectrum.
- onara 6y agoreCAPTCHA is an accessibility and privacy nightmare. There are better alternatives like OOPSpam API that gives a score and works in the backend so no interaction with the user.
- j3th9n 6y agoReCAPTCHA v3 gives a score and works in the background too.
- onara 6y agoThat is not entirely true. If your threshold is low then it appears and you get accessibility issue. Not to mention tracking hell of out the users.
- j3th9n 6y agoIt doesn't appear automatically, it's programmable [1], you as a developer decide what to do with a low score, you could ask for extra verification for example. I agree with the tracking and privacy issues with ReCAPTCHA. [1] https://developers.google.com/recaptcha/docs/v3#programmatically_invoke_the_challenge https://developers.google.com/recaptcha/docs/v3#programmatic...
- onara 6y agoThanks for the link. I didn't know the developer could prevent reCAPTCHA from appearing.
- chrismorgan 6y agoYou’re confusing multiple badly named products by Google. You’re thinking of Invisible reCAPTCHA rather than reCAPTCHA v3. reCAPTCHA v2 is the “I’m not a robot” checkbox widget followed by challenges if Google doesn’t like you. Invisible reCAPTCHA is reCAPTCHA v2 but the site initiates verification instead of the user being given an “I’m not a robot” checkbox widget to click; but if Google doesn’t like you, it’ll still trap you in the purgatory¹ of puzzle solving. Site operators can then blame Google, for all the good that does. “Invisible reCAPTCHA” is a bad name for the product, because it’s not invisible. reCAPTCHA v3 never presents a challenge for you to solve, but decides a score (in practice, I’ve only seen 0.1, 0.3, 0.7 and 0.9) where higher means Google’s feeling more friendly towards you, and it’s up to the site operator to decide what to do with that score—whether to simply deny access to people that Google doesn’t like (catastrophically bad and widely illegal, as it blocks legitimate users with no recourse) or to do something else. But now the liability for blocking real people is clearly with the site operator and not Google. But of course far too many people will ignore Google’s “don’t gate on this alone” direction and just see the higher version number and assume it must be better than reCAPTCHA v2. “reCAPTCHA v3” is a bad name for the product because it’s not a CAPTCHA, as there’s no challenge; it’s straight fraud detection. — ¹ Some hold it’s hell, rather than purgatory.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoIt's not that sad tbh, as a legitimate user I'm sick and tired of proving I'm not a robot 20 times a day. I'd love for recaptcha to become irrelevant.
- kingsuper20 6y agoCould you (or anyone) give some insight into what spam protection really entails? Talk about a useful open source chunk of software.
- bdamm 6y agoAbuse is an arms race, so I'm not certain it can entirely be "open source". Someone has to man the servers to adapt as the assault develops. There can be tools that are open source, but without a foundation that is running services, it's just a bunch of dead end code.
- wpietri 6y agoAbsolutely. I agree the key is less code than rapidly updated data. Source networks, browser headers, client behavior, target links, content markers. Spammers may be awful, but some of them aren't stupid. IF they discover something isn't working, then they'll change up their approach. And it can't be an open service, because you're just helping the smart ones to hide better.
- anigbrowl 6y agoDisqus has passable spam and toxicity detection (the latter via a third party) but many sites don't bother to make use of it. As a result a great many disqus comment sections are absolute cesspools of spam, bigotry, and threats of violence.
- jedberg 6y agoThe main thing is training a model. Every time you mark something as spam or off topic, it trains a model so that it can identify similar things in the future. You can train your own model, but it will work better with a lot of data. Open sourcing it would be hard, because you'd have to trust everyone else to classify things correctly, or you'd have to review every input yourself. A spammer could easily sneak in a lot of false positives or false negatives to throw the entire model off.
- clankyclanker 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mbirth 6y agoAlso one account where I can see all the comments I've left on the various sites with their replies. And if I feel like it, I can easily remove old comments - even after my nickname and/or email changed, I've deleted all my cookies and/or got a whole new system. I just need to be able to log into my Disqus account. And the site I'm commenting on doesn't know my email address.
- weird-eye-issue 6y agoYou could use a closed source spam protection API from an open source project. Best of both worlds. Oh that is actually what Wordpress does with Akismet
- onara 6y agoYep There are privacy-friendly alternatives like OOPSpam API you could integrate to any comment systems.
- weird-eye-issue 6y agoNice self promotion w/o any disclaimer