5 ms·
Before I bought a Mac, a year and a bit ago, I used Linux on a variety of laptops. Most brands (Sony,IBM,Toshiba,Dell etc). I spent a sizable chunk of time figh
by axod 18y ago
Before I bought a Mac, a year and a bit ago, I used Linux on a variety of laptops. Most brands (Sony,IBM,Toshiba,Dell etc). I spent a sizable chunk of time fighting with hardware, drivers, whatever sweeping changes the linux devs decided to implement that broke everything...
Since owning a mac, I have the power of linux, but it just works. It's known fixed hardware. Of course it's going to work properly.
I remember spending a day fixing the crap the linux devs piled on me when they decided to replace /dev with the udev system or something. Then there was some update to libc which broke everything on my system. Those days aren't fun days.
I remember spending ages trying to get wifi adapters to work properly under linux.
For some, this may be enjoyable, productive work. Definitely if you're into hardware, or trying to learn linux, but I can't imagine the advantage of having linux on the desktop over OSX.
Obviously I have Ubuntu within parallels on my MacBook just incase I want to have an exact server environment or something...
- SwellJoe 18y agoI'll point out that it is now possible to buy laptops, from several vendors, pre-installed with Linux. Lenovo makes several ThinkPad models with Linux, Dell has three or four models, as well. And they cost less than their Windows-running twins, generally. So, you have the power of Linux, and it just works. The biggest source of trouble for me with Linux has always been wireless drivers, because manufacturers are so tight with their specs...Intel has a fully open WiFi chipset, and it's the one included in all of these "for Linux" systems, and it works really well. I remember spending a day fixing the crap the linux devs piled on me when they decided to replace /dev with the udev system or something. Yeah, I remember that day, too, but only because I was interested in it. My distribution upgraded without a hitch, and I wouldn't have even noticed the difference if I weren't specifically doing development work on a kernel driver that had a device interface. Then there was some update to libc which broke everything on my system. Never happened. Unless you're using some oddball build-your-own Linux, libc is not going to be upgraded in an incompatible way. No distro worth a damn would do that, and I'm absolutely certain that Fedora, CentOS, RHEL, Debian, and Ubuntu have never broken everything on your system by providing an incompatible libc version. You did that to yourself, either by using a crazytown distro without proper dependency management (though I can't think of one that has ever broken libc in the way you describe) or by replacing libc manually and against the better judgment of your package management tools. I'm not saying Linux is foolproof (obviously, it isn't), but if you choose a well-supported distribution, and follow its recommended upgrade processes, you will simply never see the problems you're describing. I've managed Macs, and I can say with confidence that they are no friendlier after an upgrade than a Linux system. You know they've changed their user management system in pretty dramatically incompatible ways several times since OS X was released? Even recently, one user related weirdness led to a friends laptop becoming completely unusable (it was in a sort of death loop seemingly trying to start the login process)...the only advice we could find on the web was to restore from backups--I poked around in single user mode, but couldn't make much sense of it, so I didn't touch anything. She handed it off to the Google techstop folks, who worked on it all day, and finally wiped it and reinstalled the OS. Perhaps all parties involved are just idiots...but it seems to me that things can go wrong with Macs, as well, and you've just not had time to run into it.
- abstractbill 18y agoNever happened. Unless you're using some oddball build-your-own Linux It did happen, to me also. To be fair, I think we were both using Gentoo at the time, which probably qualifies as "oddball" I guess, but Gentoo does (or did - I haven't kept up) claim to have a good package manager with proper dependency management.
- william42 18y agoI used Gentoo but switched away when some expat change caused tons of apps to break at once and some dependency cycle prevented me from fixing the problem. I switched to GoboLinux, which is sorta like Gentoo but better.
- SwellJoe 18y agoI think we were both using Gentoo at the time, which probably qualifies as "oddball" I guess More than oddball...Gentoo is just plain retarded. But you have my sympathies and condolences for the hours you lost to Gentoo. And never let it be said that Gentoo has good package management. Clever, perhaps. But not good. Good package management requires good packaging policies, good maintainers, and good technology. The software involved is only a small part of the picture, and while one could possibly convince me that portage is a reasonably good piece of software, the other two pieces of the equation simply aren't there for Gentoo. And, because the policies of Gentoo are actively hostile to stability and predictability, even if the project does gain enough good maintainers, it will never be a suitable operating system for servers, or any system that you don't want to reinstall every couple of months (unless, of course, their policies change...at which point, the reasons people are so excited about Gentoo will have evaporated and all that will remain is Yet Another Linux Distribution).
- axod 18y ago"More than oddball...Gentoo is just plain retarded." I think that's a little harsh. I still use it on a server or 2, it's got some very nice organisation not seen in ubuntu or others. Also having it compile everything should give performance gains. I still like the whole use flags, rc system etc.
- khill 18y agoI've been using linux exclusively for about 10 years and I can sympathize with your experiences. However, in the last three years I've installed linux on two laptops for work - a Dell Inspiron at my previous job and a Lenovo T60 at my current job. In both cases, installation was flawless, hardware was autodetected correctly, and everything "Just Worked". That includes OpenGL, audio, and wireless. For reference, I'm using Ubuntu. In the last couple of years, linux installations have become much, much better in this respect. I'm sure that people running bleeding edge hardware or using certain components still struggle to make it work with linux. However, the need to compile drivers and fix issues caused by updates is no longer a guarantee when runnig linux.
- lally_singh 18y agoFrankly I buy macs b/c they're vendor-supported unix boxes. Outside of my personal gripes with Mach-O, it's a pretty good unix.
- cypress-hill 18y agowho the hell needs the "vendor"? i can get better unbiased advice out of online forums. even after going to freebsd i continued to use ubuntuforums, because the advice tended to be great. the arch wiki also rules. i would rather use a forum or irc then call some dipshit on the "vendor" support line. all i want from a hardware vendor is a sane warranty. otherwise they can keep their worthless phone monkeys
- axod 18y agoThe reason is that Apple guarantee that OS X, will work with their hardware. If it doesn't, they better fix it quick, or risk the wrath of everyone. With Linux, you might have some unsupported hardware, and that's that. Your choice is either to write drivers yourself, wait until someone else does, or buy different hardware.