4 ms·
And still no support for spatial audio with AirPods Pro? I continue to be mystified why spatial audio only works for watching movies on iOS devices. I know the
by crazygringo 6y ago
And still no support for spatial audio with AirPods Pro?
I continue to be mystified why spatial audio only works for watching movies on iOS devices. I know the official explanation is that the host device needs an accelerometer and gyroscope... but Apple TV's tend to stay still, you know.
It baffles me why you can get amazing spatial audio watching a movie on a tiny screen... or regular stereo audio watching a movie on an amazing huge TV... but not together.
(And if you haven't tried spatial audio with content that supports it, you should -- it really is stunning, kind of like the difference in going from black-and-white movies to color movies, only for your ears.)
- minikites 6y agoThe entire advantage of Apple is supposed to be that they're one company and all of their products work together, but that's becoming less and less true over time. AirPods and HomePods barely work with Macs compared to how they work with iOS devices. Apple has boasted about how you can fit all of their products on a conference room table, yet they don't actually work together well. What else are they doing with their time?
- harikb 6y agoI use AirPods just fine with Macs. I also easily switch between Mac and iPhone reliably and easily. What particular annoyances are you talking about?
- _ph_ 6y agoHaving spatial audio of the AirPods Max supported on any device you want to watch a movie on? And up to date, Homepods are not really supported on MacOS, though support seems to be in 11.3.
- tonoto 6y agoI recently came over to "Apple"-world after years of listening to all the fanatics/ambassadeurs who proclaims "it just works". I've been using an Apple AIO computer (model Imac 5k) for a couple of years as a web browser, but recently I started the switch from Android eco system and first I bought the "pro" model of their wireless headset just to find out that they worked pretty decently (albeit, overly expensive) as bluetooth headset even to my Sony phone, then I bought the their mobile phone ("12 pro") and also their smartwatch ("series 6"). After I switched from Android I did a reset to my headset and paired it with all my Apple devices. Success rate of switching sound between computer, phone and watch against the headset varies alot. Sometimes it just works but almost half of the times I have to fiddle with sound output in computer to select the "airpods pro" or in the phone to select the bluetooth headset. Not to mention that even directly in the phone I had troubles to answer in Hangouts with sound output/input redirected to the headset, even though it says "Airpods pro" beneath the bluetooth symbol to show it is actively connected to de device. Also in the computer there are several occassions where the "wheel" is spinning, in the attempt to connect to the headset. This thing "it just works" feels like a fraud to me, I can't remember since Android 2.x (I never had the 3.x, only 4.x, 5.x, 6.x, 8.x, 9.x and 10.x) that I had sound/connection issues like this. Although I have not had a bluetooth headset linked between my Linux computers and Android phones, I have shared multipoint bluetooth headsets between two different android phones and switched over without these kind of obstacles I now have.
- harikb 6y agoI agree there is lot to improve. My issues have been mostly with having the Airpod Pro sit in the case for 1-day+ and then take and find out it hasn't charge one of the pods. Case had charged, but it didn't somehow charge the pod. However my experience with pairing/connect/disconnect has been better than any other brand I have tried. Taking it from the case to trigger the connect has been absolutely ground breaking. I don't particularly care for the Small size, lack of a neck strap or any of those fancy features.
- tonoto 6y agoStrange enough, I've had differences in charge level for both "pods" - like 10% difference if I remember correctly, at one or two times. But never that it became an issue for me leaving one pod without power. I'm impressed with the battery times, due to them always beeing charged by the case. That is a neat functionality that works good for me. I just wished that the connect was a seamless experience for me too. About size, big plus for portability. A tiny minus for the fitting. I would absolutely not trust them during mobility such as running or biking. In that sense my wireless sleep "headphones" from Bose are way better fit with a "wing"/spring on the rear side to secure them.
- spoonjim 6y agoiOS is the future of the company. Mac will shrink asymptotically as a fraction of their overal R&D investment.
- bredren 6y agoThe livestream just said the new iMac supports spatial audio.
- ahmedalsudani 6y ago> The livestream just said the new iMac supports spatial audio. Isn't GP talking about Apple TVs? Did I miss something?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dbbk 6y agoWell they just announced that Spatial Audio works on the new iMac, so I have no idea what's going on.
- willseth 6y agoIt's unclear if what they announced includes support for the AirPod-type spatial audio or if it only means they are extending Spatial Audio branding to include the virtual surround feature of the new iMac's speaker array.
- crazygringo 6y agoIt appears to be a "different" spatial audio. It seems to be attempting to recreate "surround sound" using the iMac's built-in six-speaker system. Not via connected AirPods, sadly. Which is definitely more than a little confusing.
- crazydoggers 6y agoI’m guessing because the vast majority of the market with a 4K Apple TV is not watching in stereo, but in surround with something like Dolby Atmos. Edit: For those unfamiliar, spatial audio is a post processing effect that attempts to simulate surround, whereas most home theaters are going to be watching material that has discreet location and channel data, meaning a much more realistic surround stage.
- crazygringo 6y agoA lot of people watch TV/movies at night with headphones instead of speakers, in order not to wake up the kids, grandparents, someone who works early, etc. Especially when you want to fully experience those big loud action sequences without making the house actually rumble. This is for people when they aren't using their speakers at all. Edit in response to your edit: I think you may be misunderstanding Apple's spatial audio feature. It's not simulating surround out of stereo audio, it's simulating a sound stage out of the discreet location and channel data you're talking about. It requires surround sound input, it won't operate on stereo input. The surround stage is shockingly realistic if you try it.
- crazydoggers 6y agoIt’s still post processing to create a sound stage to a stereo signal. Nothing wrong with that, but for instance if I’m watching a movie on an iPhone or something, I’m assuming I can’t get the true audio experience of the film. When it’s a movie I really am into, then I’m going to watch it in full surround, with discreet speakers. 7.1 to stereo headphones is always a compromise whether it’s Apple spatial audio, or Dolby Atmos for Headphones. And absolutely I get your point, that it’s great for watching it at night. I’m just guessing their market for 4K Apple TV is more home theater people. Usually when I’m watching at night with headphones I’ll be on the iPad. Again it’s not that I don’t see the use case, I just wouldn’t call it “baffling” since the market is a little different.
- crazygringo 6y ago> I’m just guessing their market for 4K Apple TV is more home theater people. Nope, it's just average people with TV's in their living rooms. Apple TV (even the 4K version) is just an average consumer product. And at least for non-tech people I know who have families, watching Apple TV at night with Airpods is super common.
- culopatin 6y agoI also find it very weird that they would focus this movie oriented feature on a device that is not great to watch movies.
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoTaking a random guess, I think it’s because the location of the AppleTV doesn’t help identify the location of the actual screen. There would need to be some awkward configuration step (redone every time the AppleTV or screen moves) that Apple just wouldn’t ask its customers to do.
- bredren 6y agoPerhaps Apple will release an accessory that attaches to the TV itself.
- enos_feedler 6y agoOr maybe… a TV! I mean at this point it all but certain they will converge on an all in one unit. It just needs to pack enough differentiators into it
- crazygringo 6y agoYou don't really need an awkward configuration step, though, because you can rely on the fact that users are usually looking at the screen. Just take the median orientation of the earbuds over time, and you're configured. You can also rely on the fact that the user is almost certainly looking directly at the screen every time they navigate the UX with the remote.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stouset 6y agoThis gives you direction but not distance.
- crazygringo 6y agoIn my testing with spatial audio, the effect doesn't seem to change with distance, so I think direction is all it relies on. I could be wrong though, it might be doing something subtle. But even if it were, it would still be fine to fall back to a default distance of 2m or something.
- _ph_ 6y agoI had hoped for spatial audio in an updated AppleTV, as I finally want to be able to use that great feature of the Airpods Max. It is strange that Apple creates devices like the Airpods Max and then not support them with their hardware.
- kalleboo 6y agoYeah that's the feature that would have sold me both a new Apple TV as well as a new pair of AirPods. As it is now, our current Apple TV and my current Audio Technica BT earbuds work fine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]