6 ms·
The Discipline of DE (1978) [video]
- hummusandsushi 6y agoI was pleasantly surprised at how enjoyable the video was and the message is very clearly and directly applicable to how we carry ourselves in day-to-day life. If you perform your actions single-mindedly and with purpose, you will find that they become easier and more efficient. It is not a question of exerting more effort, but exerting it in such a way that none goes to waste.
- cleansingfire 6y agoLove this since I saw it ages ago, and despite a bit of Burrough's woo, it helped me to be careful, and strive for physical grace, in the things I'm doing. Personally, I tended to physical extravagance, and enjoyed that as a goofy hyper teen, all edges and elbows. This provided a surprising rationale and reminder to move more carefully. Now, I reconsider when I find myself flailing or thrashing, so that instead of pushing harder, or searching for bigger hammers and longer levers, I pause and reconsider. It's a bit of nonviolence to the world that results in care for yourself, with impacts like walking more gracefully, or remembering to turn a wrench so that you don't injure yourself when it slips.
- sidcool 6y agoI watched it but did not get it. ELI5 anyone?
- qntty 6y agoBasically mindfulness before it was a thing
- jlos 6y agoI think its intentionally mixing messages. It combines sincere insight into the benefits of mindfulness. However, the world the narrator speaks in is clearly a fantasy world detached from reality. The video both makes a profound case for mindfulness while satirizing its own arguments.
- dsego 6y agoDo things with intention and don't rush.
- alexdgourlay 6y agoSampled in this track by techno duo Minilogue www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZznUiv1Q5s
- tomduncalf 6y agoAha I was just about to post this. Great track. First heard it in Efdemin's mix CD "Carry On, Pretend We're Not In The Room" which is a good one: https://open.spotify.com/track/4r3NSfFXLdmTu5TDTETXF2?si=kNJxJ0bsQwmyBvvutNH4Dg https://open.spotify.com/track/4r3NSfFXLdmTu5TDTETXF2?si=kNJ...
- C-x_C-f 6y agoFunnily enough, this track is credited in the video description of the OP video under the "Music in this video" section, complete with an ad for YouTube premium...
- obventio56 6y agoAll comments so far seem not to realize this is satirizing mindfulness
- nepthar 6y agoWhy do you think it's satire? I didn't get that read.
- tantalor 6y agoIs this sincere advice? - Walk across a room with care - Open a window with care - Shoot a guy with care
- uoaei 6y agoYes? What's your problem with it? Have you ever heard of Zen Buddhism? All the "advice" you get from Zen teachings is pretty similar to this, except with more focus on not-doing as an approach to doing.
- obventio56 6y agoI guess it’s just the premise. Retiree transforms his life and solves all his problems by doing exactly what he was going before only... more carefully? And duel is certainly absurdist. I enjoyed the film, but I think it’s intention is largely opposite what is being received here.
- chasebank 6y agoI don't think it is satirical. https://www.vice.com/en/article/9aa3vy/do-easy-william-s-burroughs-and-gus-van-sant-show-you-how-to-get-things-done https://www.vice.com/en/article/9aa3vy/do-easy-william-s-bur...
- C-x_C-f 6y agoWhile the video certainly contains absurdist elements (the duchess scene gets me every time), I've always seen it as being sincere in tone. It feels a bit like a fable or a parable, in that it contains deliberately unrealistic parts to get the point across, but remains in good faith nonetheless.
- hirundo 6y agoThe first, and non trivial, step, is noticing that you aren't doing it easy. I've been working in very tight spaces where I twist myself into pretzels trying to get at a particular spot, all while wrapped up in a homemade hazmat suit, to the point where I can hardly breath or see. It has gotten better after I established one rule: No Stress Positions. Meaning, do whatever it takes to get comfortable before proceeding. Before, if my back would start to hurt from a difficult stance, I wouldn't really notice, I'd just speed up to try to get it done before my back gave out, frequently botching the job and cutting or scraping myself in the process. Now, I notice that I'm breaking The Rule, think about the topology, reposition myself, maybe add cushions, maybe spend some time to move things out of the way. Fixup my mask and goggles, and then take my time. Before I'd only take notice of my discomfort on failure, when I just couldn't do it anymore. And that resulted in a strong desire to quit. Now I spend the effort to get myself in an "I could do this all day position", and I can do it all day. I think the same thing applies to washing dishes or making breakfast. First step, just notice that you aren't doing it in easy mode. It's summed up by the old Two Bulls on a Hill joke.
- dsego 6y agoFestina lente = make haste slowly. There's another similar saying, not sure about the translation, but something along the lines of "the longer way may be quicker than the shortcut".
- Jtsummers 6y agoAnother saying: Slow is smooth, smooth is fast. Apparently from the US Navy SEALs though I didn't learn it from that context (best effort to recall my first hearing of it was my dad, who probably learned it in a military context as he was a USAF pilot). He also taught me the phrase "lazy man's load", in reference to trying to haul everything from the car to the house at once. Taking less each time reduced the risk of an accident (like dropping a bag of groceries or having the bottom tear out because it's not properly supported), even though it means more trips it (usually) produces the better result. Which also seems appropriate here, the lazy man's load is born of haste and is decidedly not the easy way in many, if not most, situations.
- yboris 6y agoI re-watch this video about once a year for the past decade. My take-away for myself is to stop getting angry at some stupid things I get angry at. To try to make stupid chores into elegant mini-games instead (speed run it optimally, etc).
- 1970-01-01 6y agoI hope nobody actually does this crap. Its not healthy.
- mannanj 6y agoWhy don't you tell us an alternative rather than just shooting down without solving the problem?
- 1970-01-01 6y agoYou can't understand this is comedy/satire? See also: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0239404/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0239404/ Same writer and director.
- Slow_Hand 6y agoThe text is sincere while the video is absurd. People can still understand the video as comedy/satire, but the point of the original text is still valid and useful. What do you find to be unhealthy or objectionable about the message of the text? It’s as if you believe that people in this thread who are discussing the merits of the text are going to act absurdly like the young man in the video.
- 1970-01-01 6y agoYes that's it, I believe that people are going to act absurdly like the young man in the video. It actually happens.
- howlin 6y agoSo far the comments here lack much context. The film here is what I believe is a student project of Gus Van Sant who went on to be a professional movie director. The narration is from William Burroughs, who's most famous for "Naked Lunch". One interesting fact about Burroughs is that he was a chronic drug abuser and managed to shoot his wife during some sort of drug fueled accident. The message in this little piece can be easily interpreted as Burroughs trying to analyzing his own mistakes that lead to her death. This is really just scratching the surface of how odd and complex Burroughs' life and psyche are. If you are a fan of surrealism, the beatnik movement or other larger than life writers like Hunter S Thomson, it's worth giving his work a chance.
- pitspotter 6y agoMaybe the 'Do Easy' strategy helps a drug user to cope with the low dopamine levels during the hangover period, i.e. when not high.
- dang 6y agoThe story is by Burroughs but that narrator is not the dry, timeless Burroughs voice, which sounds like...papyrus with ancient secrets inscribed on it, which has seen it all. Edit: here's the Voice: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-p68gSp4eE#t=5 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-p68gSp4eE#t=5 Edit 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ajahePtEaY#t=66 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ajahePtEaY#t=66 (music by John Cale) Edit 3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=daYvKq87cv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=daYvKq87cv4 Edit 4: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q9kwcJpX_Zg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q9kwcJpX_Zg
- JadeNB 6y ago> This is really just scratching the surface of how odd and complex Burroughs' life and psyche are. If you are a fan of surrealism, the beatnik movement or other larger than life writers like Hunter S Thomson, it's worth giving his work a chance. The movie Naked lunch, nominally about Burroughs, is also very much worth a watch.
- RandomWorker 6y agoI have surprising many of these OCD tics when cleaning the lab. This is surprisingly useful when working in a lab, cleanliness and order is paramount for health and safety. Then the videos divulges into some western saloon thing. :P
- JohnDeHope 6y agoI really enjoyed the absurdist element to this. I think he is simultaneously advocating mindfulness and making fun of it, both earnest and satirical, obviously silly but also serious. Absurdism is great.
- DrOctagon 6y agoAgreed. The message would be way too earnest without the absurdist elements. Come to think of it getting frustrated with our interaction with inanimate objects is completely absurd. DE is like the opposite of slapstick.
- jlos 6y agoHaving seen this for the first time, it seems the video is some kind of absurdist double entendre: it combines insightful comments about mindfulness while seemingly satirizing the entire enterprise of it at the same time. Some supportive points for mindfulness: - Treating everyday things like works leads you not enjoying them and doing them poorly. Yet the bulk amount of time in your life is spent doing these very activities.' - Finding enjoyment in perfecting simple things actually makes a lot sense, as its presented. - If you stub your toe, drop a dish, etc, and don't practise doing the movement properly you are likely to make the mistake again. Support in Absurdist: - He puts the radio, with its neatly wrapped cord, under a sink. - "Gentle old cop making a soft arrest" - the contrast between 'gentle' and 'soft' with arrest is clearly absurd. - 10 month year with 26 days - Taking your time in a gun fight. Support for Satirizing (comical critique): - The objects are clearly magical. - The utensils instantly drop exactly where they need to without sorting. - The toothpaste cup basically cleans itself. - The chair actually does move in front of him. - The contrast between the do-easy mindfulness and the ignorant way of living are infomercial-level exaggerated. The ending summarizes the absurd double-entendre: a gun-fight is a simple movement done very well in a zen sort of way (the trick to moving fast is to practice slowly), but at the same time its clearly absurd. Its also a gun-fight. You don't have time. Really great video. I'll be watching it again
- jadbox 6y agoI think true brilliance that lies in making a statement that cannot be fully interpreted as supportive, critical, or satirical. On one hand, it allows the viewer to project their oppinion onto the medium. On the other, the medium reveals a value to an viewpoint/lifestyle while also being critical of it.
- gfiorav 6y agoI get the irony here, but regardless: I'm European and live in the US. When I've travelled to the Middle East and Japan, both places struck me for people doing exactly what this video suggests. Such a calm, methodic way of handling things... made me realize that to them, we probably appear careless.
- 99_00 6y agoLove to smoke pot and do something like this. Love that it's a thing and I can attach a label to it and the idea of doing poorly executed sequences again, better. Going to try to do this more often in everyday life.
- aargh_aargh 6y agoSame video, 2x better quality (240p vs 480p): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pjQ0FNzkLQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pjQ0FNzkLQ
- dang 6y agoOk, we've changed to that from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eoOUBETTyMI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eoOUBETTyMI above. Thanks!
- stephen_cagle 6y agoI don't know why this style appeals to me so. I like that it is poking fun at while also embracing what we would call mindfulness. I like the fact that you can take most anything from it. May just be a reflection of being tired of the prescriptive (usually appeal to authority) style of so many videos/books these days.
- dang 6y agoArticles about it: https://dangerousminds.net/comments/william_burroughs_gus_van_sant_and_the_discipline_of_do_easy https://dangerousminds.net/comments/william_burroughs_gus_va... - "Buddhist noir" - nice. https://www.openculture.com/2018/07/discipline-d-e-gus-van-sant-adapts-story-william-s-burroughs-1978.html https://www.openculture.com/2018/07/discipline-d-e-gus-van-s...
- dbtc 6y agoTo see it in action, watch a pro sushi chef
- dusted 6y agoAnyone else feeling the beauty in this ? It's like hearing my own thoughts reinterpreted and spoken out aloud. It's how I've always enjoyed doing things, just so, efficient, precise and elegant.. I wonder if there's a connection between that and being slightly on the spectrum..