4 ms·
> The whole article make its look like any police interaction is somehow a thread to peoples live. In 2020 in the USA people were twice as likely to get killed
by sneak 6y ago
> The whole article make its look like any police interaction is somehow a thread to peoples live.
In 2020 in the USA people were twice as likely to get killed by a cop than killed in a mass shooting. Police killed over a thousand people in a single year.
- scotty79 6y agoPhrasing it like that makes it seem like it's some kind of freakish accident. Cops are taught to shoot center of mass of a person basically until they stop moving. They are expected to do this and are judged according to that expectation. Police is killing people because that's exactly what you expect of the police whenever policeman feels he's threatened. In USA of course, not in many other first world countries.
- Clubber 6y agoThere is a show called South Park where the two hunters find something they want to shoot (usually off season) and right before they shoot, they yell, "It's coming straight for us!" The animal, usually just grazing, looks up and has an expression like, WTF? The hunters use this tactic to get around hunting laws. >Police is killing people because that's exactly what you expect of the police whenever policeman feels he's threatened. This South Park skit reminds me of when police say, "I felt threatened."
- noxer 6y agoWhat an absurd comparison. This only tells me that being killed in a mass shooting is very very very unlikely which is in fact true. But being killed by police is also very very very unlikely in fact its de facto zero if you aren't a criminal/drug abuser and comply with police orders.
- mbirth 6y agoDid you not see recent news: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fj66LBel_WQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fj66LBel_WQ He "only" got pepper-sprayed, but now imagine if he tried to unbuckle himself using his hands where the frightened cop couldn't see them...
- noxer 6y agoWhich part of "...in fact its de facto zero if you aren't a criminal/drug abuser and comply with police orders." did you not read? Also anecdotal evidence of a bad cop interaction is not a valid argument. There are thousands of interaction that happen every day. The fact that every once in a wile a bad interaction makes the news doesn't pose any information about the actually risk. Someone drunk driving into you and killing you is still more likely to happen but it usually doesn't make national news so people do not have an irrational fear of getting killed by drunk drivers but it happens all the time anyway. And guess what It would happen even more without police making thousands of interactions.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> And guess what It would happen even more without police making thousands of interactions. This claim is dubious — there are studies showing both a modest decrease [1][2] and no correlation [3] in the drunk driving crash rate when arrests are increased. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4254192/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4254192/ [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK217455/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK217455/ [3] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/6221143_Policing_the_drunk_driver_Measuring_law_enforcement_involvement_in_reducing_alcohol-impaired_driving https://www.researchgate.net/publication/6221143_Policing_th...
- noxer 6y agoI didn't say increase or decrease. I said "...without police making thousands of interactions" If you question the negative effect that would have on drunk driving accidents, I accept that its solely based on common sense and no studies were conducted to proof it.
- sneak 6y agoBreonna Taylor was an EMT that was murdered by police while asleep in her own bed during a no-knock raid. There is no data to suggest that she was a criminal or drug abuser. Tamir Rice was a 13 year old kid playing with a toy gun (which have orange tips to denote that they are toys). He was murdered by police, too. Duncan Lemp was executed by police shooting into his home at 4:30AM whilst he was totally asleep. There are many other examples, this is not an occasional, anecdotal thing. (Additionally, under the law in the US, the penalty for being suspected of crime or drug dealing is not "summary execution by police". It involves a trial.) Your claim is false.
- noxer 6y ago> Breonna Taylor was an EMT that was murdered by police while asleep in her own bed during a no-knock raid. That's absolutely not what happened. At worst this was horrible police work at "best" it was a freak accident. There is zero reason to believe that anyone was murdered. Not going into the other cases because quite frankly it does not falsify my claim even if they are in fact what you say they are. My calm was that its very very very unlikely which is true even if it happens. Just like the mass shooting you original brought up that is also very very very unlikely to kill you even trough it could happen. That does not make "police interaction somehow a threat to people" (the original statement) Just like the lottery does not make you a millionaire. And boarding a plane doesn't make you die in a fireball. You gotta look at probability in a rational way. The risk of being killed by police is very very low and as said above by not being a criminal/drug abuser and by complying it gets even lower. So low that its practically non-existent. You do dozens of things every day that have a way higher probability of killing you. Like taking a shower. The statement that taking a shower somehow poses a threat to people is still absurd and wrong.