3 ms·
No. The atomic bombs were intended to be used against Germany as well, but the Nazis surrendered before a working bomb could be deployed. The US chose Japan bec
by krapp 6y ago
No. The atomic bombs were intended to be used against Germany as well, but the Nazis surrendered before a working bomb could be deployed. The US chose Japan because they were at war with Japan and Okinawa proved just how costly an invasion would be.
Not that the US wasn't, and isn't, still virulently racist against Asians in many ways, but we didn't undertake the entire Manhattan Project because of racism or just to show up Stalin, that's absurd.
- throwaway4good 6y agoThe last bit is a bit of a straw man isn't it? You can study the initiation of the Manhattan project if you will. But once the bomb was built, it had to be used. And America at that point was already planning for the world after it had defeated the Axis powers and that is where the dark racist geopolitcs comes in.
- krapp 6y ago> The last bit is a bit of a straw man isn't it? It's a repudiation of the premise that "They (the US) chose Japan because its people were not white." Had the war in the Pacific ended first, the US would have dropped the bombs on Germany. Simplistic reductionist arguments like that only risk turning what could be interesting discussions into race-baiting flamewars. As far as dropping the bombs as a display of power to Stalin goes, it's a conspiracy theory without hard evidence. I'm sure the US was aware of the wider geopolitical context of what they were doing, but if all they wanted was to show Stalin they had a working bomb, they could have dropped one on Alaska or anywhere. The US' primary concern at the time was ending the war.
- throwaway4good 6y agoMy source for this is documentation on display in the Hiroshima museum. Make of it what you will. PS: I don't judge the US for being racist - everyone was racist by today's standard anno 1944.
- resoluteteeth 6y ago> My source for this is documentation on display in the Hiroshima museum. Make of it what you will. PS: I don't judge the US for being racist - everyone was racist by today's standard anno 1944. There's probably an actual argument to be made for it being motivated by racism but what you have posted here is not doing much for the case.
- thehappypm 6y agoJust admit you're wrong here. The USA did not nuke Japan out of racism. It nuked Japan because they were the only enemy left.
- throwaway4good 6y agohttps://ieer.org/resource/commentary/always-the-target/ https://ieer.org/resource/commentary/always-the-target/ “Always” the target?: While U.S. bomb scientists were racing against Germany, military planners were looking toward the Pacific By Arjun Makhijani As for racism; well it was a different time. But look at the vilification of the Japanese and the American internment camps during the war. Plus the subsequent wars in Korea and Vietnam.
- kryogen1c 6y agoeverything you have said doesnt prove racism is a factor, much less the primary motivator. youre either using "racism" with a definition that makes it meaningless or using it incorrectly. the japenese killed americans in a surprise attack while US was not involved in the war. civillians were sacrificing to support the war effort. its not some mystery why the US would be eager to bomb japan and end the war. similarly, the japenese internment camps in the US were hardly inexplicable. when youre at war with people X, its reasonable to be at war with ALL people X, not just the ones in uniform. spycraft is a thing, and people often bear allegiance to their homelands. there are subtle types of sabotage that any enemy can perform. you have to prove the US wanted to kill the japanese becuase of their race, instead of the much more obvious and well-supported claim that US wanted to get revenge and end the war in the same blow.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Not that the US wasn't, and isn't, still virulently racist against Asians in many ways Compared to what? During what time period? That's a very broad statement that doesn't stand up to analysis. The US gave freedom and rebuilt many Asian countries (Indonesia, Philippines, etc.) after WW2. If that's virulent, then I want more.