2 ms·
Journalists are often not great at understanding statistics. That is how we got so many misleading news. 914 to 918 per 100,000 is a tiny change. It might be c
by inglor_cz 6y ago
Journalists are often not great at understanding statistics. That is how we got so many misleading news.
914 to 918 per 100,000 is a tiny change. It might be caused by subtle differences in the two groups that have nothing to do with alcohol. If anything, the study shows that having <= 1 drink a day is basically the same as being a teetotaler.
Two drinks a day, OTOH, are visibly worse for health (914 to 977).
- kqr 6y agoJust saying it's a tiny change because "it feels that way" doesn't make it so. When ranting against misleading news, I think your approach of argument from assertiveness is slightly dishonest. A bit more rigorous would be to compare maybe the Beta distribution with a=915 to a=919 and b=100,000 in both cases. Or Poisson distributions with lambda 914/100,000 and 918/100,000. I don't know whether Beta or Poisson are better fits. I don't even know how I'd find out. Abd of course, that's still a fairly handwavy approach and I'd love for someone to show me how it's done for real. But just saying it's noise without quantifying it seems to me exactly as misleading and irresponsible as the original news, only biased in the other direction.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIn case of humans and health, the biggest variable is age. Biological aging is strongly connected to higher risk of serious diseases. (See Makeham-Gompertz law; this is the Gompertz component.) If you have groups of 100 000 people, but there are just a few slightly older people in the other group, the incidence of age-related diseases is expected to be higher. Then there are subtle things such as "how many people in group A vs group B live next to a motorway or suffer from higher levels of ambient noise". Not to mention the cultural differences (religious fasting or absence thereof etc.) Picking up huge groups of people that are perfectly equivalent is very, very hard. But I am not a professional either. I studied algebra, not statistics, we only had a year-long course in the basics. Maybe I was too handwavy.
- B1FF_PSUVM 6y ago> Journalists are often not great at understanding statistics. Perhaps, as comrade Upton Sinclair put it, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it."