4 ms·
What's this obsession with increasing housing density? Population in the developing world is leveling off. Most of the developed world is already at "peak child
by Animats 6y ago
What's this obsession with increasing housing density? Population in the developing world is leveling off. Most of the developed world is already at "peak child".[1] Housing shortages come from migration to cities, not more people.
[1] https://ourworldindata.org/peak-child https://ourworldindata.org/peak-child
- rocqua 6y agoThe rules against density have prevented a lot of demand from being met. It makes big cities where people want to live unattainable for many because of price. It also forces many people into long commutes. This makes them less happy, cause large amounts of pollution, and creates huge traffic jams. By increasing density, biking to work becomes easier. Similarly, public transport becomes a lot more effective. In general it leads to much more efficient cities.
- lentil_soup 6y agoAs a single data point, I live in one of the most dense european cities and home prices are insane. Probably a mix of speculation, tourism and other policies. While density might play a part it's not a silver bullet. As with everything, the solution is probably custom to each city and region
- exporectomy 6y agoPerhaps it's not dense enough compared to how economically valuable living there is. Otherwise, why would people live in an overpriced city instead of a cheaper one? Why do you live there? Surely for most residents, it's because of high-paying jobs.
- lentil_soup 6y agoMost people live here because they are from here, local jobs are definitely not high paying. Could they move to a cheaper city? Probably, but that has big life implications, people might take the economical hit to be able to stay close to home. What I mean to say is that in this particular case it's not just a density problem. There's problems with tourism, there's problems with speculation, there's problems with general inequality. So the solution is not just build more, it's way more nuanced.
- rocqua 6y agoIs that density caused by confining the city to a small footprint? If not, how do the suburbs look? Are there density restrictions on the suburbs? And on a non-financial view, how is the situation w.r.t. public transport and car usage? I fully agree that density is not a silver bullet. My point is that artificially reducing density when there is a high demand for living places is bad. Both because of supply and demand, and also because of positive externalities from (voluntary) high density living. It does seem to sometimes be the case that high density cities increase demand so much that prices remain the same, or increase. That sucks from the perspective of economic equality. However, from a perspective of creating value, this is amazing. It means that these dense cities give the same value (enjoyment of living there) to more people. Especially if (as you say lower in the thread) people aren't moving to the city for jobs, but for the city itself. That essentially shows that the city is just really nice to live in. Sadly, it suggests that density sometimes does not help economic equality. But it is still a massive improvement to have people want to live in the city so much!
- agent008t 6y agoAm I missing something or is the solution fairly obvious? Anyone who can work remotely should be encouraged to do so. And that is a lot of office workers. People should be encouraged to move to cheaper towns and work from coworking spaces (or from home). Services will follow (cafes, hairdressers). This will lead to more equal development of a country and decongest the cities. Instead, at least in the UK, the government is completely squandering this unique opportunity. They seem eager to force us back into the pre-pandemic life patterns. Why? If people don't like the high street anymore, so what? The economy exists to serve the people, not the other way round.
- shuckles 6y agoThere is much unmet demand for living in dense areas, and it’s unmet largely for reasons of policy set by incumbents and not technology. LA’s zoned capacity was higher 50 years ago than it is today. Same with San Francisco.
- cozzyd 6y agoAs household sizes have gone down, it stands to reason that household density should go up.
- polskibus 6y agoIn addition to that, efficient city is in contrast to what psychology says humans need for happiness, ie. space, access to green land, low noise, low pollution environment. Maybe we should convert to many small cities, allow telecommute instead of piling people on top of each other?
- flukus 6y agoOverall population growth is leveling off, but urbanization (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization) continues, cities keep growing and rural areas keep shrinking, at least relatively. There's possibly a degree of causation too, people delaying or avoiding having families because they aren't affordably in the cities that their jobs are in.
- andrewjl 6y agoThe environment, for one thing. Cities emit much less CO2 on a per capita basis. E.O. Wilson put out a bold plan turn half of Earths landmass into a wildlife preserve[1] and something of that scale can only be accomplished by building very, very large cities. The other reason is economics, cities inherently generate greater GDP per capita, especially in highly creative fields. In parts of the world where real estate isn't subject to "hot money", they're also engines for economic advancement and social mobility. (And to an extent, they're somewhat that way in the US, UK, and other locations as well, but their impact is heavily diluted by lack of housing affordability.) [1] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200318-the-worlds-largest-nature-reserve https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200318-the-worlds-large...
- wahern 6y ago> What's this obsession with increasing housing density? Wealth inequality is compounded when urban real estate appreciates faster. The Economist blithely ignores why governments are obsessed with homeownership, though--because homeownership tends to negatively correlate with wealth inequality. That is, the greater rate of homeownership, the less wealth inequality. So rents may be stable in Germany, but so is its moderately high wealth inequality.[1] However, mortgage burden positively correlates with wealth inequality. Using easy financing to make ownership more common tends to cancel out the former effect. So, really, what correlates with lower income equality isn't nominal ownership, but actual equity. [1] See https://www.oecd.org/officialdocuments/publicdisplaydocumentpdf/?cote=ECO/WKP(2019)58&docLanguage=En https://www.oecd.org/officialdocuments/publicdisplaydocument... and https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/10.15609/annaeconstat2009.136.0027.pdf https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/10.15609/annaeconstat2009.1...
- eptcyka 6y agoEasy financing only drives up prices.
- presentation 6y agoI personally think the issue isn’t really homeownership per se, but homeownership as an investment. The biggest long term difference I see between my life here in Japan and in San Francisco is that people here view their homes as a place to live in, and that there’s no shortage of options of places to buy - but don’t expect a profit on it unless you’re within 5 minutes from the most coveted stations. Otherwise, you buy because it’s better value than renting, and so I see that my Japanese friends can be young, middle class, and still benefit from the economies of scale of living in the largest city on Earth. Meanwhile countless people are excluded from San Francisco’s business nexus because it’s just too expensive to justify. Meanwhile my landlord had already bought over 10 properties to rent and had accumulated otherworldly wealth from the fact that he was born 30 years before me. Many of my friends have virtually 0 prospects of ever reaching home ownership in a major American city, and so long as everyone’s home values rises indefinitely, it’s only going to become more unattainable. COVID has changed the calculation, but I still think cities will remain economically dominant into the future.
- 6y ago
- neilwilson 6y agoMainstream economics is obsessed with gravity theories. One of the underlying beliefs is that ramming people into smaller spaces causes more things to happen (agglomeration). Whether that leads to a better quality of life is beside the point when the metric you are optimising towards is national GDP growth.
- akomtu 6y agoIf you had a farm with cattle, would you want each cow to live in its own small place or would you pack all cows efficiently under one roof and move them around in bulk?
- neilparikh 6y ago> What's this obsession with increasing housing density? The real question is "What's this obsession with decreasing housing density?" Cities don't have zoning laws mandating minimum densities, they have laws mandating maximum densities. If there was an "obsession with increasing housing density" as you claim, wouldn't we see the opposite?
- shellfishgene 6y agoOne factor that's often ignored is that the space per person has steadily increased over time. For example, in Germany the average floor space per resident has doubled from the 60s to now, so the same city now requires twice the living space, even with zero population growth! It seems to be similar in other countries. This is mostly due to fewer people living in the same space, not necessarily because housing units are growing.