3 ms·
On the whole, does FIPS improve security or is it one of those compliance checkboxes that actually reduces security of those who know what they’re doing?
by vlovich123 6y ago
On the whole, does FIPS improve security or is it one of those compliance checkboxes that actually reduces security of those who know what they’re doing?
- er4hn 6y agoFIPS 140 provides a standard for assuring that a product has implemented their crypto correctly. It has its warts but overall it skews very close to otuer published sources of algorithms. I think the biggest differences lie in handling edge cases and key generation. That said, receiving a FIPS certification is a huge effort in terms of time and money. I think it is tragic that neither NIST nor the NSA provide a already certified library you can integrate in. That would save enormous amounts of effort. Fun fact - lots of FIPS certifications are white labeled openssl with the latest set of FIPS requirements so I'm not even being that radical.
- x3n0ph3n3 6y agoIt's often a requirement for any Federal customers. It's a mixed bag in terms of security, since it does force you off of _very bad_ algorithms, but it doesn't always support the best algorithms.