6 ms·
As I interpret it, it's not even that. The instruction is to remove his personal email from the MAINTAINERS file, not to halt work on the project. Now, maybe
by ajross 6y ago
As I interpret it, it's not even that. The instruction is to remove his personal email from the MAINTAINERS file, not to halt work on the project. Now, maybe that was said offline, we certainly have no evidence. But the most obvious interpretation is that Lijun Pan was employed by IBM to work on the Linux kernel driver for this piece of IBM hardware, and IBM (unsurprisingly) wants all contributions credited to them and not to individuals. Most employers would have similar rules if you ask them. Certainly mine wouldn't want me using my personal address for stuff they paid me to do.
Is the way this was done maybe a bit hidebound, corporate and uncharitable? Yeah. It's IBM, duh. But absent other evidence it doesn't seem like this devleoper is being pulled off a project for using a personal email.
- momothereal 6y agoThe fact that the entire entry was removed, as opposed to simply changing the address, combined with the tone of the message, makes me think otherwise. However, I'm basing this off the exact same information as you (presumably), so it's a bit of a moot point until someone wants to pitch in with more authority.
- scintill76 6y agoAgreed. “remove yourself completely from the maintainers file”
- m463 6y agoAs I interpret it, he cannot make updates at all, even though he's using his personal email address. The important bit might be: what state he is in. Then to a lesser extent, what kind of work he does for IBM and what kind of work he does on the kernel.
- JonathonW 6y agoFor a little additional context, a few days ago, Pan removed himself (using his IBM email address) from the maintainers list in the same file and added himself (using the gmail address) to the reviewers list. The linked commit removes Pan entirely. There’s more going on here than is visible from the out-of-context quote in the commit message.
- nodamage 6y agoSince there are other IBM employees listed in the same file it sounds like the issue is with this specific employee?
- dheera 6y agoCan the community disapprove the pull request and show it to IBM that they don't control the kernel?
- geofft 6y agoIt would be a little nonsensical for the community to say that IBM does not control the "IBM Power SRIOV Virtual NIC Device Driver," which is located in the drivers/net/ethernet/ibm directory, and which according to this very same MAINTAINERS file is maintained by three other IBM employees.
- dheera 6y agoIf they want to control it they can create their own repo and distribute it on their website. If it's going in the Linux kernel tree it should not be subject to single-handed decisions by a corporation.
- xwolfi 6y agoThis person can also quit IBM, therefore being subject to no contractual obligation, and then change the "IBM Power SRIOV Virtual NIC Device Driver" entirely free of constraint as long as their code pass review. IBM has no control over the code, only the people it pays to change it.
- egberts1 6y agonot really. there is this stipulation of using a clean room in which to introduce your idea in order not to be sued for “stealing” intellectual property. And often times, the same person cannot be used in that clean room.