5 ms·
Why is it obviously wrong?
by XorNot 6y ago
Why is it obviously wrong?
- gct 6y agoYou can fuse above iron but you spend energy to do it instead of releasing energy I guess?
- adrian_b 6y agoI do not know what the other poster had in mind. While fusion does not end at iron 56 (whose nucleus has the lowest mass per nucleon), the quantities of heavier nuclei produced by fusion decrease very steeply with increasing atomic mass, becoming low beyond the isotopes of nickel, very low beyond the isotopes of zinc and negligible beyond the isotopes of germanium. The elements heavier than zinc are produced mostly or completely by other kinds of reactions, e.g. neutron capture.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoBecause heavier elements have higher binding energies than iron.
- jjk166 6y agoIt's the binding energy per nucleon that matters. The nuclei you're producing needs to have a higher binding energy than the nuclei you're fusing do on their own. There is nothing you can fuse with iron, or any heavier nucleus, that will produce a stable element with greater binding energy than its components. Nickel-62 is actually the most stable nucleus, with the most binding energy per nucleon, but stellar nucleosynthesis ends with Nickel-56 which decays into Iron-56, which has the lowest mass per nucleon. All nuclei heavier than Nickel-62 are produced endothermically.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoYou are confusing nucleon (neutron or proton) with nuclide or nucleus. You still get extra energy from fusing a nucleon with nickel-62
- jjk166 6y agoNo, I'm not. Nuclei fuse. A proton is just a hydrogen-1 nucleus, and neutron capture isn't fusion.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoOK, Which weighs more? A nickel-62 nucleus and a proton, or a copper-63 nucleus?
- jjk166 6y agoYou don't get a copper-63 nucleus if you hit a nickel-62 nucleus with a proton, you get a copper-61 nucleus and two neutrons in the reaction: 62Ni(p,2n)61Cu Copper-63 has spin of 3/2 while nickel-62 has a spin of 0, so you can't simply add a proton (whose spin is 1/2), you need at least 3 fermions to participate in the reaction. The Copper-61 and two neutrons of course have a higher mass than the Nickel-62 and the proton.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoThat doesn't make any sense, the difference between nickel-62 and copper-63 is one extra proton. It's also bullshit, since the differences in spin get equalized by neutrinos.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoAlso note that this closely corresponds to what we see: A star would be expected to burn by fusing hydrogen into heavier nuclei, which shed helium as alpha particles once they get too heavy, eventually ending up with mostly lead and helium. Which either undergoes a fission event which fissions the heavy metals into iron, or stays the way it is, a white dwarf. No need for "exotic" physics. And it also explains the persistent failure of fusion energy, as it tries to build upon nonexistent mechanisms made up to confuse people trying to build nuclear weapons.