3 ms·
You're right. None of those people account for the time value of money. If I could get an interest only mortgage I would (where I literally pay to rent the mo
by jedberg 6y ago
You're right. None of those people account for the time value of money. If I could get an interest only mortgage I would (where I literally pay to rent the money). There are so many better things I can do with a few hundred thousand dollars now.
If you have the money to pay off your mortgage, why not buy a second house with it and rent that out? Let someone pay your mortgage while you get the appreciation? Or invest it in something else?
If you do the math, renting almost always comes out ahead of owning, as long as you invest the difference in something that gains in value.
The main reason to own is for psychological reasons. It's great if you have kids and want a place for them, or yourself, to call home.
- bumby 6y agoI think the part that needs to be factored into your analysis is the volatility/risk aspect. A mortgage may be relatively low ROI but it’s also relatively low risk compared to the market. E.g., maybe somebody has a certain percentage invested into low risk bonds. Maybe it makes sense to pare back some of that and put it towards their mortgage during a period when bonds are being crushed. Neither bonds or the mortgage return will compete with a general index fund in terms of return over a long period of time, but the index fund is in a different (higher) risk category
- splistud 6y agoThe 'mortgage return' will compete very well over a long period of time, especially if you ensure the comparison is fair. For instance, 15 years in, when your mortgage note is 60 to 70% of prevailing rent or lease, consider the return on that savings as part of the 'mortgage return' - because this is part of the return in the form of inflation hedge.
- Y_Y 6y agoI think this statement is a bit strong. The price/rent ratio varies greatly between places and times. Around here it's between 30 and 40 years, that makes it very difficult to make money by borrowing to buy a place to rent out.
- mywittyname 6y agoIn such markets, the bulk of the ROI is not the rent checks, but tax savings and appreciation of the underlying asset. Real estate looks a lot like the stock market anymore. People value companies on metrics beyond simple revenue, profits, and dividends. With RE, investors understand that wage growth in a region flows into housing at a compounding rate due to leverage and are capitalizing on it. So long as Seattle or LA have companies that pay above average wages to enough employees, housing prices in those regions should continue to grow at a a rate somewhat relative to differences in wages. What constitutes "enough employees" seems to be relative to how constrained housing growth is. In LA, housing prices are driven by probably the top 20-30% of earners.