3 ms·
I still say we should move into the direction of doing away with user passwords altogether and viewing the device itself as the basis for authentication. Every
by bob1029 6y ago
I still say we should move into the direction of doing away with user passwords altogether and viewing the device itself as the basis for authentication.
Everyone has a personal computing device in 2021. Who is still sharing a family computer and needs to switch user accounts? How many businesses still operate with shared workstations?
Adding additional sessions (i.e. devices) to my netflix account should be as simple as scanning a QR code from an already-authenticated device with my unauthenticated device. This pattern feels magical with applications like Whatsapp web interface. It instantly works and you had to remember nothing. Virtually everything along the consumer segment could work like this.
There are obviously pedantic edge cases that we could invent all day, but there are also blindingly-obvious value paths we can go down as well. Recovery of lost devices is clearly a big issue with this scheme, but its the same resolution in any scenario. You resort to SMS/Email/Phone to re-establish your identity on the new device and use some emergency token issued as part of recovery to bootstrap the whole thing again. It's exactly the same shape problem as forgetting your password.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoWhat happens when one of the "personal" devices gets lost? How do you authenticate to the device in the first place? I also don't feel like lugging around my employer's laptop wherever I go, but I sometimes happen to need to check an email or something when I'm at a friend's house (so I can't register the device). Should I not be able to do that? > Who is still sharing a family computer and needs to switch user accounts? My client does. People work in shifts, it would make absolutely no financial sense to have double the number of computers. It would also be a pain to have to switch screens, etc. Or much more expensive to equip everyone with laptops.
- bob1029 6y ago> What happens when one of the "personal" devices gets lost? How do you authenticate to the device in the first place? The device you initially register on is the one that has access. Subsequent devices could chain off of that one. If you lose a single device and have others on the same account, it's trivial to recover. If you lose all devices on the account, it's the same scenario as forgetting your gmail password. You go to some recovery page and follow steps to prove your identity again.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoI've got this point, this allows you to maintain access to your accounts. But the question was more along the lines of: how do you protect the lost device from being used by the thief, thereby impersonating you? You presumably need some method to let the device know it's really you. So if it's not a password, what is it? I seem to remember an article a few years back of a group (probably the CCC, but I'm not sure) that managed to reproduce Angela Merkel's fingerprint without physical access to her fingers. Apple claims Face ID is more secure. But is it, really? I honestly don't know, and finger unlock was supposed to be secure, too. What happens if we find out it isn't?
- bob1029 6y ago> You presumably need some method to let the device know it's really you. Enter literally every mobile device unlock/security scheme since this all began. Which is more secure in the average case today? A) A password or passphrase, with all of its historical flaws in aggregate. B) Apple's iOS unlock feature using a recommended/default configuration, and some 256 bit session token tucked away somewhere in secure device storage. I would personally have a hard time answering this directly. Lots of "it depends", which tells me there are contexts where each scheme can make sense. If you were to apply the spy movie aesthetic here, you would probably find it much easier to coax a password out of an unwilling participant than it would be to hack open a pile of cryptographic secrets you found laying on the street.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoYou do realize that B is just something on top of A, and not instead of A, right? The finger unlock of my iPhone doesn't let me do everything. There are operations for which the password is required even if you have the right fingerprint. So basically, the "security" of my phone is protected by my password. If I know the password, but I don't have the fingerprint: I don't care, I can do anything. I can even enroll the finger I have. If I have the finger but forget the password, I'm going to have a bad day since the touch ID feature requires me to input my password at least once a week and I cannot change the password or do any other sensitive operation. So how does this scheme replace passwords? Sure, it's more convenient, since people don't have to type the password 500 times a day. But will they actually use strong passwords? When I've initially set up my iPhone it asked to set up a code in addition to the fingerprint. That default was a 4 digit pin[0]. That's some high security right there. --- [0] This was some 4-5 years ago, things may have changed. I remember seeing an article grilling Apple over this default. It was fairly easy to switch to a regular password, but we're talking about the default here, which we know is what most non-technical people will use.
- dsjoerg 6y ago> Everyone has a personal computing device in 2021. 85% of Americans have a smartphone. 15% of Americans do not. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/mobile/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/mobile/ What are the stats for other countries?
- tim333 6y agoAs to what works in practice, most cryptocurrency exchange accounts, which are prime hacking targets as you can steal large amounts of money irreversibly work as follows: Enter email@address.com and easypassword1 You are then asked for Google Authenticator code, which is a six digit code based on a secret key and the time of day. It generally works quite well though it's a pain if you lose your Authenticator key (stored the in a phone app usually)
- jpindar 6y ago>How many businesses still operate with shared workstations? The ones that deal with physical objects. Ones that control machinery, keep track of objects in warehouses and stores, etc.