3 ms·
3D printers -- both resin and filament-- are everywhere and cheap today. And there are many great affordable devices with e-Ink--I have several Amazon ebook re
by fortran77 6y ago
3D printers -- both resin and filament-- are everywhere and cheap today.
And there are many great affordable devices with e-Ink--I have several Amazon ebook readers that I use every day.
I'm not sure I was harmed by any patent.
Many of the things we talk about on Hacker News are covered by patents. Why do you want to shred a piece of the U.S. Constitution (assuming you're talking about U.S. patents) over eInk?
- Miraste 6y agoI believe that was GP's point - 3D printers are cheap and ubiquitous because a patent on them expired in 2009. Before that they were expensive and had little tooling or support: useless outside large corporations, despite all the technology involved existing for years and years. I don't know the patent situation of e-ink but patent law was incredibly counterproductive in the case of 3D printing.
- robinsoh 6y ago> patent law was incredibly counterproductive in the case of 3D printing. I don't work in the 3d printing industry so I don't have enough knowledge to know that with any level of confidence. It sounds plausible but not sure if it is true. That's why, I am curious whether you do, ie: do you work in the 3d printing industry? How confident are you that the recent proliferation was due to an expiration of a counterproductive patent (which one?) rather than just technologies, volume, demand, industrial production finally coming together and becoming mass market? Has there been any actual detailed analysis or study proving this? The reason I ask is not because I am opposed to the claim, rather I often see unsubstantiated claims like this go unchallenged for a long time. In the case of E Ink, I even saw someone blog that statement and they cited an HN comment about E Ink patents that I had challenged and the poster never responded, and then someone cited that very blog post in another HN comments so it became a circle of references where all the dots on the circle are unsubstantiated.
- monocasa 6y agoThe lynch pin FDM patent was 5,121,329 which expired in 2009; there were similar later patents in the space around SLA printing that expired in the five years following that. There's been plenty of analysis both from industry and academia that it was indeed holding back the proliferation of 3D printing technology. Being in a adjacent field of other robotic control that utilized 3d printing for our own prototyping before and after the proliferation I can also confirm the patent licensing being a major impediment to proliferation of the technology. We had high enough margins that we could spend $100k on a 3d printer before 2009. But the field has been revolutionized since then from the democratization and even our own processes changed heavily once we could have a bank of printers rather than just one. Sort of like the change of a a company sharing a mainframe with a guy dedicated to keeping it going versus ubiquitous microcomputers.
- Miraste 6y agoI'm not in the industry, just a hobbyist, but this is well established. There are dozens of companies making printers, filament, models, tutorials, software, and innovations that legally couldn't exist while this patent was active. Universities, makerspaces, and small to medium sized businesses (and hobbyists) didn't have access to the tech because of it. Here is the patent in question: https://patents.google.com/patent/US5121329A/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US5121329A/en And here's a short explanation of the impact: https://creax.com/insights/the-influence-of-patents-on-3d-printing-evolution/ https://creax.com/insights/the-influence-of-patents-on-3d-pr...
- robinsoh 6y ago> And here's a short explanation of the impact: https://creax.com/insights/the-influence-of-patents-on-3d-pr https://creax.com/insights/the-influence-of-patents-on-3d-pr... I read the article and came away unsatisfied. I was hoping to see a clear analysis like "here's an inventor who was blocked from producing his product by a patent infringement lawsuit" and here's a series of patent infringement lawsuits that blocked inventors from innovating. Instead I felt the main points were broken due to contradictory statements in the article. They started with: "Commercialising these kits was actually an infringement on Stratasys’ patent but Stratasys did not stop this from happening." Which contradicts: "Everything changed by the end of 2009, the expiration date of the famous Stratasys’ patent after 20 years." I see that Reprap was commercialized in 2006 prior to the patent expiring which clearly contradicts above as well. There's limited factual data in this article. Claims like "Everything changed" seem like strong claims that ought to be substantiated rather than defended using "feels right" kind of explanations.
- Qwertious 6y ago3D printers aside (I don't know enough to comment), literally everyone I've seen who claims e-ink is held back by patents is either 1) speculating or 2) repeating hearsay and can't provide a source. Regardless of the issues with patents in general, in the specific context of e-ink it's an unsubstantiated myth until someone provides some hard evidence. E-ink patent speculation is especially problematic because everyone on HN agrees that patents are a problem, so it sounds truthy and people want to repeat it as an example of the evils of patents.
- fortran77 6y agoEverytime "e-ink" comes up here in any context, we see people doing a hit-and-run post about patents, with nothing to back it up. I'm wondering what the real agenda is here. Is there some competitor trying to do some sort of astroturfing?
- zokier 6y agoits just a meme, and people are bitter because they love the concept of cool eink gadgets that never materialized so they want to have some scapegoat.
- dmwallin 6y agoWhat competitors?
- Teever 6y agoIs it every time? It is something that I've only noticed about e-ink posts in the last two months or so. Prior to that I've always wondered why they were so expensive. The posts that I've seen regarding e-ink and patents seem to be very persuasive.
- Qwertious 6y ago>The posts that I've seen regarding e-ink and patents seem to be very persuasive. Have you seen any comment that provides actual evidence of causality between e-ink's failure to take off and patent encumberment?
- zokier 6y agoBut things turned out pretty well in the end? That is the whole point of patents: they expire. You say the tech existing for years and years, but few years is very short time, even 20 years is not that long time. Just need a bit of patience.