3 ms·
the problem with these solutions is that they make two assumptions: 1. that language can be controlled via a top-down process, that a fiat issued from those wi
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
the problem with these solutions is that they make two assumptions:
1. that language can be controlled via a top-down process, that a fiat issued from those with the power to determine things will create a language of greater moral stature than before.
2. that there is a sort of slippery slope of meaning that humanity follows when imprinted with language, and thus man meaning a man and not a woman and man meaning humanity will cause people to go around thinking that women aren't human. It is true that much of misogyny assumes that women aren't human, but there is a huge inductive gap from noticing this to jumping to the conclusion that the structure of our language is responsible.
That said of #2 I think there is a weak function of this, but the moral crusaders always act like it is as strong as iron and must be broken or the world will never improve. Hence #1.
- josteink 6y agoI believe another aspect of point 1 is that, they believe that whatever injustices are out there in the world, will be fixed if they just change the language to be of such a format that such injustice can no longer be described. It's naive at best.
- zimpenfish 6y ago> they believe that whatever injustices are out there in the world, will be fixed if they just change the language No, they believe that a relatively easy, cheap change can help them promote a more diverse environment which, hopefully, will be removing a small pebble from a giant wall. Remove enough of the pebbles, and the wall will eventually give away.
- google234123 6y agoIt may also have the opposite effect: Normal person sees this and thinks "wow, the far-left is crazy (is this a banned word?)".