5 ms·
> Subsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords How is it a windfall for landlords? If the rent prices are going
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> Subsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords
How is it a windfall for landlords? If the rent prices are going up, they will be making the money regardless of whether the renter is paying for it or the government is paying for some of it.
If your point is that a subsidy will shift demand and increase the price, that is exactly what we want! A price signal to the market to build more housing to accommodate everyone who wants to live there including displaced communities!
> lean into displacement
What does this mean? I think there is some level of societal interest in preventing displacement, there are negative externalities from displacement that the market can't properly price in.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> How is it a windfall for landlords? If the rent prices are going up, they will be making the money regardless of whether the renter is paying for it or the government is paying for some of it. Subsidies for a population that otherwise couldn’t afford it will accelerate the rate at which market price increases, especially since those subsidies will also increase as the market price does. It’s like student loans and college prices, but worse.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> tudent loans and college prices, but worse. It's not worse if there is cost-sharing. And as I said above, > that is exactly what we want! A price signal to the market to build more housing to accommodate everyone who wants to live there including displaced communities! Inevitably, trying to keep displacement from happening is going to increase prices for newcomers. The question is whether we want to do that in a way that incentivizes increasing supply or one that keeps people out.
- pdonis 6y ago> A price signal to the market to build more housing And, as basic economics will tell you, sending such a signal to a market is a windfall for people that already own the underlying asset in that market--i.e., landlords. They get a windfall because they bought the asset when the market undervalued it (because the price signal was not being sent).
- whimsicalism 6y agoSure, but if paired with dezoning, the loss due to the elimination of rent-seeking through constricted suply would likely be larger decrease for landlords than the increase from demand surge from the subsidy.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Sure, but if paired with dezoning, the loss due to the elimination of rent-seeking through constricted suply would likely be larger decrease for landlords than the increase from demand surge from the subsidy. Landlords benefit from dezoning; increased density increases the rent value realized per unit of land area, even if it might decrease it per unit of living area, even without subsidies (and the slumlords that go whole hog on density will make those islands of private communities that don’t even more valuable, so long as the crime and other unattractive effects of the former can be kept out of sight, out of mind, from the latter. The people opposed to dezoning aren’t landlords, they are residents who prefer low density conditions.
- airhead969 6y agoIIRC, by modern economists that inflation doesn't work like that in the real world. Real estate is based primarily on desirability, the order-of-magnitudes of wealth influx, and comparables. Overall, housing prices are uninvolved in changing inflation, but mostly externally-caused inflation changes housing prices slightly.
- candiodari 6y ago> If your point is that a subsidy will shift demand and increase the price, that is exactly what we want! A price signal to the market to build more housing to accommodate everyone who wants to live there including displaced communities! As long as that same government is using law (ie. violence) to prevent building more housing, no amount of subsidies can be effective. What do you intend landlords do? Hire an army to defend cheap housing from the government?
- whimsicalism 6y agoYes, subsidies should be paired with dezoning. Yes, law includes the threat of coercion, I don't see what adding that little tidbit does to improve your point.
- lurquer 6y ago> I think there is some level of societal interest in preventing displacement, Why? ‘Historic populations’ is a euphemism for Black in most cases. In most large cities I’ve lived in, there is typically a section of town plagued by bad schools, high crime, bad infrastructure, and crumbling residences, and it is usually monoethnic. Why is this a good thing? It seems that whites in the more affluent areas and suburbs are willing to throw a lot of money at these ‘historic’ populations so that the residents won’t move to their side of town. Kinda perverse. ‘Ethnic’ neighborhoods in large cities are quaint. Sometimes they become tourist attractions. But, in large part, many are simply ghettos and the faster the ethnicity is integrated into the larger housing market, the better for everyone.
- bombcar 6y agoThose neighborhoods are often targeted for redevelopment the moment the ghetto starts improving, and as the ethnic residents are often renters, they have little recourse when it begins. See: gentrification.
- airhead969 6y agoIsn't it typically a windfall for richer people posing as poorer and clever poorer people for improved survival who can utilize or resell earmarked subsidies meant for extremely struggling people?
- whimsicalism 6y agoWelfare fraud is one of those instance of things where it is really salacious so people love reading about it in the media but is not actually that common. Rent control laws are a different beast altogether because they are not means tested typically.