4 ms·
I'm shocked that they're estimated as being only 30x more dangerous than conventional elevators. I would have guessed thousands of times more dangerous.
by Waterluvian 6y ago
I'm shocked that they're estimated as being only 30x more dangerous than conventional elevators.
I would have guessed thousands of times more dangerous.
- hibbelig 6y agoHaving used one, I guess people just behave differently. For example, when riding an elevator, you might be looking at your smartphone, but if you take the stairs, you don't. Getting onto and off a paternoster is pretty exciting, so you won't be bored enough to look at the smartphone :-)
- zeotroph 6y agoConventional closing-doors elevators are just absurdly safe, even stairs (moving or non-moving) are more dangerous. People die around elevators when climbing onto the roof when it gets stuck or forcing the doors open instead of staying put. Once it gets moving again bad things can happen. But as hinted at in the safety section, with modern sensors and some brains behind them paternoster can be made safe. You can even make them wheelchair accessible by gradually stopping a cabin and informing all other passengers about that. And when a department in a large and busy office building is spread across a few floors then a paternoster is the most efficient way of moving between floors.
- throwawayboise 6y ago> Conventional closing-doors elevators are just absurdly safe, even stairs (moving or non-moving) are more dangerous. I used this argument when my workplace was encouraging people to "take the stairs" for supposed health reasons. It was rejected because science and statistics are only accepted when they support one's desired conclusions.
- Symbiote 6y agoThe health improvements might outweigh the risk of injury from falling on the stairs. This is the case for cycling vs driving to work in at least some cities.
- Someone 6y agoThey’re moving slowly (they get their efficiency from as good as eliminating waiting times, not from moving at high speed), and (typically) are only used in areas where most of the riders are healthy adults (personnel lifts in office buildings) And as another user already said, they look scary enough to make you pay attention.
- nicklecompte 6y agoI think there’s a lot going on in that 30x stat and I wish the citation was better: - most elevator accidents occur during maintenance, which I assume is similar for paternosters. So the fact that elevators are seemingly safer for passengers might not statistically factor in much to the overall safety record: e.g. paternosters could be 1000x as dangerous for passengers but only 5x as dangerous for technicians - relatedly, I would suspect most paternosters are better maintained than most elevators and less likely to have a dangerous mechanical failure - and as the commenters stated, passengers are likely to be more alert when using a paternoster (no accidents like stepping in to an empty shaft) Regardless I suspect you are correct that a well-maintained paternoster is at least hundreds of times more dangerous for passengers than a well-maintained elevator. As far as I can tell the stats given on Wikipedia don’t refute that (but I wish I knew more about their source).
- londons_explore 6y agoWhat injuries would be common on a paternoster?
- nicklecompte 6y agoI don’t think any injuries would be common and that paternosters are safer than stairs and escalators. Intuitively it seems that crushing accidents on the extremities would be quite a bit more likely than elevators, along with tripping accidents when entering/leaving the paternoster.
- bombcar 6y agoThe obvious one (getting half in the car and getting crushed) is likely relatively uncommon - as it should be possible to make the engine weak enough that it can’t do major harm.
- cma 6y agoWouldn't the momentum of the system alone do that?
- 6y ago
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoI wonder how that compares to escalators, given how safe elevators are.