3 ms·
Cities, or rather city governments represents their inhabitants, and inhabitants are negatively affected by having lots of short term rentals as neighbours, tha
by vidarh 6y ago
Cities, or rather city governments represents their inhabitants, and inhabitants are negatively affected by having lots of short term rentals as neighbours, that is why.
If there is a big market for totally deregulated cities, I'm all for some cities choose to make residential areas free-for-all. But I certainly wouldn't want to move to a place like that.
- sneak 6y agoNegatively affected how? If it's noise, there are already rules and enforcement mechanisms for noise that can be used.
- vidarh 6y agoEnforcement mechanisms for noise are there to handle the extreme end of the scale, on the assumption that there are relatively natural limits in place because of how neighbourhoods are structured. That you don't understand this consideration suggests you have very limited experience with disruptive neighbours in a city. But also e.g. increased traffic is a consideration many places, as well as simply reduced affordability for people actually connected to the place and working there. People also pick places to live based on other factors, such as e.g. distance to schools and the like, and having density of actually available residential units driven down as such can be massively damaging to local communities, as well as drive up the costs of provisioning services as a result.
- sneak 6y ago> That you don't understand this consideration suggests you have very limited experience with disruptive neighbours in a city. Quite the contrary; I moved out of my last Berlin flat due to precisely this. Apparently uncontrolled children are a free pass to avoid any sort of noise control regulations applied to buildings. Reduced affordability is a function of supply and demand. If a place is in high demand, it is natural and expected for it to cost more to live there.
- vidarh 6y agoIt is only "natural" to you because you have decided to believe it is. You used the right-wing libertarian threat of violence trope earlier, but ignored when I pointed out libertarianism has it's origin in going further than anarchism in rejecting property rights based on a similar line of thinking: that property rights only exists as a deviation from the natural by threat of violence. This notion that arbitrary subjective political views are "natural" is pretty much always an attempt at waving away objections. In this case to others it is "natural" that we should put the ability of inhabitants of a city to afford to live there ahead of maximising profit, and that using property rights in contravention of that is a demonstration of how property rights reduces freedom.
- sneak 6y agoI was speaking in the context of the society under discussion, that employs all of these things that result in supply and demand affecting prices being "natural": * privately owned/controlled real property * market-based pricing You have mischaracterized my views ("right-wing libertarian"), and seem to have misunderstood what I was pointing out. It isn't my view that prices should naturally increase as demand does: that is the view of the society and housing market under discussion, as that is how it operates today, and the system that both the hotels and AirBnB services in those markets operate within.
- vidarh 6y agoPretty much every society around, and certainly Berlin employ all kinds of mechanisms to shield people against the impacts of unconstrained supply and demand, and restricting AirBnb is just one more example of societies employing regulation as a means to do so. By your argument this is then "normal" so what are you objecting to? > You have mischaracterized my views ("right-wing libertarian") I referred very specifically to the appeal to violence, which is a very distinctly right-libertarian argument. > It isn't my view that prices should naturally increase as demand does: that is the view of the society and housing market under discussion, as that is how it operates today, and the system that both the hotels and AirBnB services in those markets operate within. Except society is not static, and part of the view of society is that regulations are under the purview of democratically elected governments, with the power to restrict how such services operate.