5 ms·
Why should cities have any authority to tell people what they are or aren't allowed to do in their own, paid-for apartments? This seems like the worst kind of
by sneak 6y ago
Why should cities have any authority to tell people what they are or aren't allowed to do in their own, paid-for apartments?
This seems like the worst kind of "because we can" meddling.
I could imagine if, say, someone were running a call center or mini-factory in their home; there is an argument (although one I do not make) for zoning. Simply using a residential unit or building for residing by people, however, shouldn't be any business of anyone but the people so residing or the people who own/rent the space.
- switch007 6y agoThe kind of properties which are under debate are not detached farms in the countryside. They’re apartments with lots of close neighbours typically. Things are very close-nit in Europe. There are popular tv comedies about the trials and tribulations of living in apartments in European cities. Community living is taken very (some would say way too) seriously in many European countries. Honestly it’s very easy to find explanations of the problems from different perspectives if you google. (I’m on mobile)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- GavinMcG 6y agoResiding isn't the same thing as having different people in and out on a daily basis, with no connection to or accountability to the community and one's neighbors. There's also just a raw market concern: using housing stock + AirBnB as an investment/storage for wealth has serious effects on the ability of people to live in these communities. The market is amoral; it's up to us to elect leaders who constrain it with rules that reflect our values.
- sneak 6y agoWhat right do you have to use the threat of violence to constrain others with rules using a residential unit peacefully and in accordance with the safety/quiet enjoyment laws that govern normal, safe use of such space? To believe that you have some right to control the events in the home of another person (that doesn't affect you) is the part that, to me, is entirely amoral. There is no reasonable basis for it, in my view. Substitute "having boarders" with "having kinky/non-heteronormative sex" or any other thing the neighbors would object to that doesn't affect them and isn't their business to see where I'm coming from.
- vidarh 6y agoProperty rights only exist in the first place in the form of threat of violence to constraint others. It's a societal compact that comes with responsibilities, not just rights. The fact that it exists only as the threat of violence is incidentally why the person who invented libertarianism - Joseph Dejacque - opposed property rights, and cited Proudhon's famous "property is theft" in the letter that first set out libertarianism as a political ideology. It then gets comical when people try to use the "threat of violence" right libertarian mantra in defence of property. If this use did not impact neighbours, I'd be entirely with you, but it does affect neighbours. You're arguing you should have a right to harm others, while they should have no recourse.
- sneak 6y agoI've yet to see the city-level arguments against AirBnB that aren't simple money grabs by the local tax authorities, or protectionist nonsense for the large hotel businesses (which reduces back to same). Both of the cities in which I live are huge tourist destinations and maybe the harm you are describing is totally invisible or something, but I haven't seen or experienced it, or known anyone else who has, despite living in the ground-zero neighborhoods for such things. I certainly don't believe anyone has a right to infringe upon the quiet enjoyment of anyone else at home.
- vidarh 6y agoIf it was quiet enjoyment of anyone else at home, nobody would be complaining. It's exactly because that isn't what it is there are complaints. Good for you that you've not been affected. Lots of other people have, and you're arguing for depriving them of quiet enjoyment of their homes because you want people to be free to ignore the effects of their own actions on others. Incidentally I'd be all for supporting proposals to zone to allow unrestricted tourist rentals in certain places if there's demand for it. But I sure as hell would never live in such a zone.
- sneak 6y ago
- vidarh 6y agoCities, or rather city governments represents their inhabitants, and inhabitants are negatively affected by having lots of short term rentals as neighbours, that is why. If there is a big market for totally deregulated cities, I'm all for some cities choose to make residential areas free-for-all. But I certainly wouldn't want to move to a place like that.
- sneak 6y agoNegatively affected how? If it's noise, there are already rules and enforcement mechanisms for noise that can be used.
- vidarh 6y agoEnforcement mechanisms for noise are there to handle the extreme end of the scale, on the assumption that there are relatively natural limits in place because of how neighbourhoods are structured. That you don't understand this consideration suggests you have very limited experience with disruptive neighbours in a city. But also e.g. increased traffic is a consideration many places, as well as simply reduced affordability for people actually connected to the place and working there. People also pick places to live based on other factors, such as e.g. distance to schools and the like, and having density of actually available residential units driven down as such can be massively damaging to local communities, as well as drive up the costs of provisioning services as a result.
- sneak 6y ago> That you don't understand this consideration suggests you have very limited experience with disruptive neighbours in a city. Quite the contrary; I moved out of my last Berlin flat due to precisely this. Apparently uncontrolled children are a free pass to avoid any sort of noise control regulations applied to buildings. Reduced affordability is a function of supply and demand. If a place is in high demand, it is natural and expected for it to cost more to live there.
- 6y ago