6 ms·
Cuomo and Schmidt push to cap price of internet to $15 for low-income NewYorkers
- tjs8rj 6y agoI wonder if it would make more sense to just have a profit cap. Like “internet must be provided to low-income New Yorkers at cost + 10%”. That way it’s always at least profitable to reach more people. The predictable result of the above is plenty of people getting cheap internet, but perhaps many people won’t get it at all because it doesn’t make any sense for Verizon to get the internet to them if they can’t recoup their investment - so they simply won’t. The above “profit cap” preserves the incentives for Verizon while achieving the boost in consumer surplus.
- dheera 6y agoWhat is "at cost"? If they increase everyone's salaries in Comcast by 50% then "at cost" increases by 50%. Or they could order 5-star Michelin dining delivered by helicopters to WFH employees and call it a "business meal", and "at cost" would be higher as well. Too easy to abuse.
- the-dude 6y agoLet me introduce you to Hollywood accounting : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- karmakaze 6y agoThe way to maximize profits in a "cost + 10%" scenario is to maximize cost x market, thus maximizing the 10% x market. Setting an indirect target is the quickest way to having a bad economic policy--if you want affordable internet legislate it and let the market figure out efficient ways to achieve it.
- tjs8rj 6y agoGood point. There has to be a better way than price caps though, price controls are well studied and have a tendency to reduce aggregate consumer surplus
- wetpaws 6y agoYou are not driving prices down by regulating them, you are driving them down by introducing more choice and competition, something that usa ISP market fundamentally lacks.
- markvdb 6y ago> You are not driving prices down by regulating them, you are driving them down by introducing more choice and competition Deregulation has proven _not_ to work for internet service providers. They're natural monopolies and oligopolies and as such antithetic to free market competition. There are some relatively good examples around the world of regulated, utility like fiber networks in particular that _do_ work at actually encouraging free market competition between internet service providers.
- janeroe 6y ago> Deregulation has proven _not_ to work for internet service providers. Proved by whom exactly? It works perfectly in the rest of the world. I've got a choice of 5 internet providers. People living closer to the central part of the city have 10 to 15.
- southerntofu 6y agoMy experience from western Europe is that only regulation forces ISPs to play fair with competitors. Even while the law is VERY VERY clear about it, they're still playing deaf and you essentially have to go to court to have the law applied (which smaller providers can't afford). Deregulation means supremacy of the private company, without any legal recourse, which can never be fair to users.
- markvdb 6y agoI am genuinely very curious to learn about a deregulated place with 15 competing providers available to a single place to live. I wonder what drives that rare phenomenon. Please tell me more about this!
- hutrdvnj 6y agoWhere are the places to live in new york, if you are on a low-income?
- ardit33 6y agodude, NYC is 8.4 mil people..... Queens, Bronx, half of Brooklyn (aka east new york), etc... even Manhattan has lots of low income housing, and of course Harlem You'd be surprised, but NYC is one of those places where there are more low-er income folks than most other cities.
- austincheney 6y agoThe only description of what that $15 per month actually buys is broadband. The idea of a maximum price cap seems kind of ridiculous compared to a minimum service criteria, like a free meal at a soup kitchen compared to a minimum service guarantee.
- shadowmore 6y agoImagine living in 2021 and still thinking this propaganda talking point from 1949 still holds any weight with anyone. We know competition doesn't work. Competitors get bought out. We know the stock market doesn't work. Money raised gets used to automate away jobs, not expand and increase the number of human beings actually needed by the company. We know pricing doesn't get corrected, at all, because everyone who runs businesses or owns property is so rich they are able to self-sustain and ignore any market signals urging them to adjust prices. None of the free market capitalist tenets actually work the way they're described, and there's a growing proportion of the population realizing this finally. It's just unfortunate they're being steered towards communism because the communists are currently the loudest opponents of this absurd system built on lies.
- exabrial 6y agoThis is one of the stupidest comments I've ever read on hacker News. Capitalism has lifted more people out of poverty than any other political system in the history of mankind.
- q3k 6y ago> Capitalism has lifted more people out of poverty than any other political system in the history of mankind. Not really: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/29/bill-gates-davos-global-poverty-infographic-neoliberal https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/29/bill-g... , https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2019/2/3/pinker-and-global-poverty https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2019/2/3/pinker-and-global-...
- kyberias 6y agoThis is an opinion piece from a 39 year old economic anthropologist.
- millsmob 6y agoI guess that automatically disqualifies it then. A 39 year old economic anthropologist couldn’t possibly know anything that I don’t already know. It’s crazy to take different points of view into consideration when forming an opinion!
- op03 6y agoMissing is Verizon's reaction. On the one hand, Eric Schmidt says the Telcos have overbid in the 5G auction and don't have cash left to roll out new networks without price rise, and on the other hand he pushes price caps. If they go through in NYC why should the rest of the country also not require it? And whats Big Telco's response then? Just a weird ass character pushing random shit just like he did at Google.
- idownvoted 6y agoForget the nursing home deaths and sexual harassment allegations: Cuomo can count on his family-dynasty’s network to clear his name. In this case, with providing him with an issue for him to coattail, while that issue doesn’t need him nor necessarily benefits from him as a sponsor
- rasz 6y ago$15 internet, $2000 rent, checks out.
- southerntofu 6y agoThey both suffer from the same problem, of being treated as a private market and not as common/public goods. Housing and Internet should be free for everyone, just like food/healthcare/education...
- Dma54rhs 6y agoIs this really mainstream thinking now in America? None of those things are free in Europe and I've yet to find people promoting these insane ideas here, while at least online I can read about these mysterious things Europeans get free for or have.
- southerntofu 6y agoSo is anticapitalism becoming mainstream in the USA? I would say yes, more or less: https://www.commondreams.org/news/2019/10/28/poll-sponsored-anti-communists-discovers-70-us-millennials-ready-ditch-capitalism https://www.commondreams.org/news/2019/10/28/poll-sponsored-... Also, historically these ideas were pretty common in the USA, with anarchist IWW being the biggest union of its time. And what you call "these insane ideas" is actually following articles the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as approved after the second World War. Do you consider basic human rights to be insane? Also worth noting, most things are not "for free" in Europe. The little rights we have our ancestors fought hard for, and they are being dismantled as we speak in the name of neoliberalism. Not so long ago France had one of the best Education and Health systems of the world, but that ship has sailed because of the desire to privatize everything and sabotage public infrastructure in the name of private profit. See also David Graeber's talk on managerial feudalism and the revolt of the caring classes: https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-11241-from_managerial_feudalism_to_the_revolt_of_the_caring_classes https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-11241-from_managerial_feudalism_...
- 6y ago
- southerntofu 6y agoJust dropping by to mention nycmesh.net an amazing self-organized Internet Service Provider. They're not everywhere just yet but where they are they're for sure providing the best (volunteered) service for the lowest money. They're currently connected to two Internet Exchange points and have hundreds of antennas. See their map: https://www.nycmesh.net/map/ https://www.nycmesh.net/map/ We need more self-organized cooperatives like that, whether in the ISP world (like guifi.net or ffdn.org federation) or in other areas of life. That's the only way we can effectively defeat capitalism without relying on our corrupt governments.
- ignoramous 6y agoSee also: https://peopleschoice.coop https://peopleschoice.coop NYC drivers are also at it with https://drivers.coop https://drivers.coop
- ftth_finland 6y agoIt just so happens that 15€ is a typical price point for 100M uncapped, unlimited 4G service in Finland. $15 for Internet service for all isn’t out of reach.
- mam2 6y agoSame in france